Western Influence on the Modern Japanese Home

During the Meiji period in Japan, there were many developments in the urban sphere, especially in the home. Edward S. Morse, an American observer, recorded his thoughts about Japanese housing and modernisation in his book Japanese Homes and Their Surroundings (1886). In his book, Morse writes about the architecture, arrangement, and construction of the Japanese home, while comparing them to homes in the West. Throughout Morse’s account of the Japanese home, there are comments of both admiration and criticism. It is in Morse’s criticisms that the cultural differences present between the West and Japan become clear. Morse’s account shows how Western expectations of domestic comfort and home design shaped perceptions of Japanese homes, which suggests that the modernisation of Japanese homes was not simply a wave of new innovation efforts, but was a more conscious effort of modernisation partly influenced by Western ideas.

Morse’s account features many opinions regarding the structure and contents of the Japanese home, some of which he regarded as quite admirable. Morse specifically enjoyed the craftsmanship of the Japanese home, writing, “their methods were not only the simplest and most economical, but they answered all the requirements. One is amazed to see how many firemen can gather upon such a roof without its yielding.”1 Morse had a few positive comments about the Japanese home, mostly about the structural ingenuity and architectural design of the home. However, despite any positives that Morse found, Morse had several fundamental issues with how the Japanese home was constructed, finding the Japanese home particularly deficient in privacy as well as comfort. Morse thought it uncomfortable that the divisions used in Japanese homes were primarily sliding doors or non-permanent dividers: “In the Japanese house, on the contrary, there are two or more sides that have no permanent walls.”2 Morse finds the lack of permanent walls to be a design flaw, one that contrasts with the homes in the West, which often featured multiple permanent walls and doors to shut spaces to ensure privacy. The core theme present in Morse’s account is how frequently he uses Western standards as a measure for the successful construction of a home. Morse often uses Western expectations and norms of domestic comfort, e.g., enclosed spaces and less open-concept construction. These criticisms of what Japanese homes lack in comparison to Western homes eventually become the very aspects that are incorporated into the Japanese home.

Morse’s account reflects an early stage of Japanese home modernisation, when Western ideas began to influence the Japanese home. Morse’s account can also be better understood when positioned within the broader context of Japanese housing reform and modernisation. In Jordan Sand’s House and Home in Modern Japan, he describes how several significant changes occurred in domestic environments between 1880 and 1930 (this includes Morse’s writings in the Meiji period). Sand writes, “In the final stage of the conversion, rooms gain distinct functions (significantly including a separate bedroom for the couple), floor-living is abandoned, and the ‘empty ceremony’ of traditional guest reception gives way to family leisure.”3 Sand is describing the work of a prominent Japanese modernist architect, Tanabe Junkichi. His vision of comfortable “Western-style living,” complete with functionally divided rooms, is the exact ideal that Morse found lacking in the Japanese home from before, showing the integration of Western domestic ideals eventually becoming physically present in the Japanese home.

There are several elements that the Western onlooker Edward S. Morse disliked about Japanese homes, one of which was the seating arrangement, specifically that of floor sitting. Morse states, “The sitting posture on the floor is painful…I find that our chairs are painful to the Japanese until they become accustomed to them. “4 This again proves Western influence, as down the line, domestic spaces in Japan began transitioning from floor sitting to chair sitting. In Housing in Postwar Japan, Ann Waswo writes, “the western-style, chair-sitting way of life that had been confined to the DK began to spread”5 into other areas of the home over time. Demonstrating that Western ideals eventually became incorporated into Japanese homes. Ann Waswo also explains the transition from traditional Japanese-style furnishings to the adoption of Westernised furnishings. Waswo writes, “the workshops and factories that sprang up to supply that market soon branched out into producing other items of western-style furniture.”6 The furniture production here demonstrates demand for Western-style furniture pieces, now showing that some Western ideals were not only integrated into the Japanese home, but some were even popularised.

Morse’s Japanese Homes and Their Surroundings speaks to how Western ideals began to influence certain elements in the Japanese home during the Meiji period in Japan. Morse’s account is useful as an early perspective during the start of Westernisation efforts in the Japanese home. Additionally, Morse’s admiration, as well as his criticism, reflects how Western cultural expectations eventually became physically manifested in Japanese domestic spaces. Sand’s House and Home in Modern Japan builds on Morse’s account by demonstrating how Western ideals manifested in tangible, physical changes in Japanese homes. Ann Waswo’s Housing in Postwar Japan demonstrates how this trend of Westernisation in the home extended into later time periods in Japan. All of these developments show that the modernisation of Japanese homes was not just about architectural improvements or innovations, but rather a transformation of domestic spaces that was partly influenced by Western ideals for the home.

  1. Edward S. Morse,  Japanese Homes and Their Surroundings (Boston: Ticknor and Company, 1886), 19–20. [↩]
  2. Morse,  Japanese Homes and Their Surroundings, 7. [↩]
  3.  Jordan Sand, House and Home in Modern Japan: Architecture, Domestic Space, and Bourgeois Culture, 1880–1930 (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Asia Center, 2003), 178. [↩]
  4. Morse, Japanese Homes and Their Surroundings, 12. [↩]
  5. Ann Waswo,  Housing in Postwar Japan: A Social History (Abingdon: Routledge, 2013), 93. [↩]
  6. Waswo, Housing in Postwar Japan, 73. [↩]

Sanitation & Colonial Rule in Manila (1903–1904)

The Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health describes sanitation and disease in the urban environment of Manila from September 1903 to August 1904. During this time, Manila (as well as other areas in the Philippines) had been battling the bubonic plague, an epidemic that took place under American colonial rule. The Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health was therefore written by the American colonial authorities and presents public health interventions they implemented during the years of the plague outbreak. The report reveals many things about the American colonial perspective, particularly how important sanitation measures became, and how sanitation became associated with economic growth and prosperity, racial distinctions, and colonial governance. Ultimately, this report demonstrates that American officials viewed sanitation not only as a means of preventing disease, but also as an important tool for regulating urban spaces and the local population in those spaces.

This report reveals a significant connection between sanitation and economic growth. The Commissioner in the report stresses that while sanitation is clearly a humanitarian issue at heart, it should also be valued for economic reasons, arguing that public health investments would later on produce great financial returns.1 This section of the report is most interesting, as it tries to convey that putting time, effort, money, and resources into sanitation is necessary for a number of reasons, not merely the more obvious health risks/issues associated with poor sanitation practices. This section of the report also reveals the motivations behind which issues the colonial administration chooses to prioritise, because the report very clearly connects sanitary efficiency with the prosperity of the Philippines, which also serves as a testament to the success of the American administration overseeing it.2 Because of this, sanitation becomes an issue of high importance.

Aside from economics, the relationship between sanitation and colonial authority/administration is an important theme across many colonial territories, like that of colonial Singapore for example. The Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health and Brenda Yeoh’s examination of municipal sanitary surveillance in colonial Singapore have some significant overlaps that speak to colonial administrations and their aims and wishes for their territories. In Yeoh’s piece, Yeoh describes how the British authorities used sanitation and sanitary regulations to exert control over urban spaces in Singapore, which frequently disrupted already established practices among Asian inhabitants living there.3 The American authorities in Manila, as observed in the Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health, much like in Singapore, used sanitation as a way to expand government intervention into everyday/public life. As Yeoh argues, the regulation of sanitation played a key role in shaping the power dynamic between the colonial authorities and the populations they governed. (Yeoh, Contesting Space in Colonial Singapore, 102 )) Thus, both in colonial Singapore and Manila, sanitation served as an excuse to intervene and regulate daily life.

The Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health also provides important insight into social/racial distinctions prevalent in colonial Manila at the time (1903–1904). In the report, there is an examination of mortality statistics, comparing the death rates across different racial and national groups. There are several noticeable disparities in these statistics. The data provided shows that there were significantly higher death rates among the Filipino population than among the American colonists. The data also shows that certain districts were associated with different social and racial populations.4 Although these statistics are meant to reveal differences in mortality, the report reveals how disease was understood within the frameworks of certain pre-existing race/class hierarchies. This is evident through the mention of certain urban districts and how they were perceived as particularly unhealthy, while conditions contributing to disease were interpreted through the characteristics of their inhabitants. The report observes that districts with larger Chinese populations experienced lower mortality rates than those inhabited by the “poorer class of natives.”4 This quote demonstrates how American authorities interpreted patterns of disease, that is, through their existing racial and socioeconomic divisions, associating particular urban spaces with the populations inhabiting them.

These social and racial distinctions can be better understood in Colonial Pathologies by Warwick Anderson. In Colonial Pathologies, Anderson explains that the framework for American tropical medicine in the Philippines was shaped by racial assumptions and biased colonial ideas about hygiene and civilisation.5 The Commissioner’s language in the Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health is also reflective of this broader relationship between American medical knowledge and colonial authority. By discrediting Filipino practices and classifying them as insufficiently scientific, American officials could then justify more American intervention into local communities under the guise of helping the more “ill-informed” Filipinos. This here is an example of how the medical, administrative, and sanitary practices enforced by the American colonial authority in Manila all reinforced the supposed superiority of Western ideas.

The Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health is reflective of how colonial administrations and their regulations in Manila were concerned with far more than disease prevention in their sanitation efforts. By associating sanitation with economic prosperity, public health interventions became a high priority and, perhaps more importantly, a marker of the American administration’s success and legitimacy. It is no wonder sanitation and public health intervention measures became of the utmost importance during the plague outbreak. In many ways, sanitation efforts became a way to assert power over local Filipinos. Dismissing any Filipino opposition to colonial rule, as well as disregarding their medical practices, was justified through a composed colonial hierarchy where Filipinos fell beneath American colonists. The Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health shows just how vital a tool sanitation efforts came to be for keeping the control in the hands of the American administration.

  1. Bureau of Public Health, Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health, September 1, 1903, to August 31, 1904 (Manila: Bureau of Public Printing, 1905), 7–8. [↩]
  2. Bureau of Public Health, Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health, 8. [↩]
  3. Brenda, S. A. Yeoh, Contesting Space in Colonial Singapore: Power Relations and the Urban Built Environment (Singapore: Singapore University Press, 2003), 102–104. [↩]
  4. Bureau of Public Health, Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health, 11-12 [↩] [↩]
  5. Warwick Anderson, Colonial Pathologies: American Tropical Medicine, Race, and Hygiene in the Philippines (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2006), 132–133. [↩]

Tropicality in Joseph Dalton Hooker’s Himalayan Journals

Himalayan Journals, written in the year 1854, provides insight into how tropicality was observed and interpreted in South Asia, specifically India, through the lens of foreign travellers. The author of Himalayan Journals, Joseph Dalton Hooker, a naturalist and botanist, explores Darjeeling in India. Hooker describes Darjeeling as its own separate haven within India, an environmental refuge of sorts, from other areas in India that had an “unhealthy” climate (like that of the Indian plains). Hooker’s Himalayan Journals provides a closer look into colonial perspectives regarding nineteenth-century India. Hooker’s Himalayan Journals demonstrates that British colonisers dissected India, divvying up colonial Indian territories into certain sections, with each section categorised into different climatic spaces, with climatic spaces being attached to ideas about health, race, and social organisation. Hooker’s Himalayan Journals uses tropicality and environmental conditions in India to categorise which parts of India were dangerous tropical India, versus a temperate, healthy India suitable for European settlement.

As a British botanist, Hooker, in writing Himalayan Journals, shows a thorough knowledge of flora and fauna, weather and climate, and geography. Within Hooker’s account of climate, longstanding British understandings and prejudices about South Asia are also present, particularly through his descriptions of the climate and environment. Hooker first states that in order for Europeans to feel comfortable settling in the British Indian colony, they would need to be assured that the climate was temperate. Hooker writes, “the health of Europeans may be recruited by a more temperate climate.”1 This idea is present throughout Hooker’s writing. While Hooker describes Darjeeling itself, he more frequently focuses on how Darjeeling affects the Europeans inhabiting it. Hooker asserts that statistical data showed “the value of the climate to Europeans suffering from acute diseases” and argues that European troops arriving in Bengal should not be sent to Calcutta, but instead should be sent to Darjeeling.2 Hooker’s racial prejudices become most apparent when describing Europeans leaving the Indian plains as “sickly, pallid or yellow, soft and flabby.”3 This line of thought is consistent with Hippocrates’ argument that differences between populations could be explained through their environments. The understanding is that climate, seasonal variation, and geographical location are all influences capable of shaping human health.4 With this understanding also comes the understanding that certain bodies are better suited to certain environments and that movement between different climates can produce illness, further solidifying this significance as well as the distinction between tropical and temperate spaces.

While the idea that tropical versus temperate spaces could have different effects on one’s health held some merit in certain ways, Hooker’s efforts to repeatedly demonstrate distinctions between these spaces in Himalayan Journals also reflected biases. David Arnold asserts that nineteenth-century European travellers writing about India frequently constructed India as a more “tropical” other world. This act of exoticising and overemphasising the “tropicality” of the colonial territories was a commonality amongst many European literary works. The illustration of colonial territories, including those in India, as overly “tropical” and possessing wildly differing climates was often attached to or associated with negative connotations, like, for example, describing a colonial territory’s climate as being “unhealthy.” Contrastingly, the European authors referred to the climate of European countries as the more ideal temperate climate.5 Hooker’s account illustrates this through his description of the plains; instead of it being tropical, it is dangerously so, but the elevated spaces in India are described as being fitting for European settlement.

The division of climatic spaces reveals racial biases present at the time. In Hooker’s account, he writes, “Natives of the low country, and especially Bengalees, are far from enjoying the climate as Europeans do”; later, Hooker claims that their susceptibility to illness was due to their cultural practices, like those of clothing, diet, and sleep habits.3 Climatic differences then become intertwined with racial distinctions, distinctions that often carry certain negative connotations. Jiat-Hwee Chang’s analysis of tropical architecture examines this distinction as well. Chang argues that the “tropics” should not be understood as a neutral or objective climatic category. Chang writes that this is due to colonial understanding, or rather a lack of understanding, of tropical nature, where racial assumptions, medical knowledge, and practices of governance all interfere with creating an objective picture of tropicality in colonial territories6 Hooker’s description of Darjeeling is demonstrative of this, when certain climates only become a colonial concern or are deemed “unhealthy” or uninhabitable as soon as they affect the Europeans inhabiting them.

Hooker’s account in Himalayan Journals is a prime example of nineteenth-century thinking about the relationship between climate and social/racial groupings. Darjeeling as a space in Hooker’s account becomes this exception, an isolated space, as opposed to the other unfavourable climates in India (like that of the tropical plains). Descriptions of Darjeeling as elevated, not low, temperate, not tropical, give insight into what exactly foreigners viewed as a liveable environment. Hooker’s insight, combined with the context of thinkers like Hippocrates, further supports this spatial division, describing the importance of different peoples and their unique climatic needs. Again, this understanding is supposedly about climate, but more closely corresponds with race/social groups, as each race or group of people is blank. Writings such as Hooker’s demonstrate the creation of a colonial geography where certain spaces or environments were assigned a different racial or medical meaning to it.

  1. Joseph Dalton Hooker Himalayan Journals, vol. 1 (London: John Murray, 1854), 115. [↩]
  2. Hooker, Himalayan Journals, vol. I, 119. [↩]
  3. Hooker, Himalayan Journals, 1:120. [↩] [↩]
  4. Hippocrates, Airs, Waters, Places, XII-XVI, in Hippocrates vol. 1, trans. W. H. S. Jones (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1923), 106–17. [↩]
  5. David Arnold, The Tropics and the Traveling Gaze: India, Landscape, and Science, 1800–1856 (Seattle: University of Washington Press, 2006), 42–54, 110–15. [↩]
  6. Jiat-Hwee Chang, A Genealogy of Tropical Architecture: Colonial Networks, Nature and Technoscience (London: Routledge, 2016), 5–10. [↩]

Urban Planning in Colonial Malaya & Singapore

As is the case with most urban planning, functionality was a main concern when drawing up urban plans for colonial Singapore and Malaya. Functionality, however, was not the only concern. Swettenham’s British Malaya: An Account of the Origin and Progress of British in Malaya (1907) and Pearson’s analysis of Jackson’s Plan both show the main priorities when planning how to construct and organise colonial settlements. Particularly in the cases of Singapore and Malaya, British authorities used urban planning as a means of reorganising colonial space to maximise economic productivity and/or administrative control. Even if plans were not successfully realised, the designs reveal British ambition and intentions which go further than simply functionality in urban planning.

Sir Frank Swettenham’s British Malaya: An Account of the Origin and Progress of British in Malaya (1907) is particularly revealing of the way in which the British used urban planning for the purpose of advancing economic priorities. Frank Swettenham, author of the aforementioned source, was a former Governor of the Straits Settlements, as well as the High Commissioner for the Federated Malay States. In British Malaya: An Account of the Origin and Progress of British in Malaya (1907), Swettenham writes from an insider perspective of his experiences within the colonial administration. Swettenham’s ideas surrounding economic growth being at the centre of urban planning became abundantly clear during his discussion of road construction in the Malay States. Swettenham describes roads in an interesting fashion. Instead of focusing on their practical purpose, getting people from one settlement to another, Swettenham instead describes the infrastructure as follows: “A bridle road was no sooner completed than small houses, plantations, and fruit and vegetable gardens sprang up along its whole length.”1 He writes that as the roads were improved upon, the villages were developing simultaneously. This means that roads, in the urban planning process, managed to alter the spatial organisation of the landscape by encouraging economic activities to be concentrated alongside them, a premeditated effort established by the colonial administration. This illustrates how space was seized as an opportunity to plan for the best economic outcome.

This is not the extent of economic growth as a main priority in the urban planning of Malaya. Swettenham additionally writes that, “revenue and prosperity follow the liberal but prudently-direct expenditure of public funds”2 especially when money is invested in “high-class roads, in railways, telegraphs, waterworks, and everything likely to encourage trade and private enterprise.”3 Here, Swettenham is stating that infrastructure is important because it increases land values, encourages private investment, and facilitates commerce, which ultimately benefits the government and its revenue. Swettenham is using urban planning by analysing the physical organisation of the settlement and connecting it to the networks of trade and private enterprise to best enhance productivity. The economic growth provided by the settlement, by proxy, benefits the administration that oversees it, once again proving economic growth and administrative interest are at the heart of urban planning in colonial Malaya.

Swettenham’s account, however, also reveals specific administrative efforts made within the colonial settlements whilst urban planning. Swettenham writes, “Sanitary Boards were instituted to regulate the markets, sanitation, slaughter-houses, laundries, water supply,”4 as well as various other aspects. The introduction of “Sanitary Boards” meant a new opportunity for colonial authorities to exercise power over civilians. Swettenham’s account also lays out other administrative positions that each coincide with a different location in the settlement, writing, “his main supports were the officer in charge of districts, originally styled District Magistrates.”5 This means that in urban planning, each district was assigned an officer to oversee it, showing how administrative efforts were implanted into the design of the city itself. In other words, with each district comes a specific administrative force to govern it. Swettenham’s account once again proves administrative control was at the forefront of urban planning, as the city was specifically planned for positions that coincided with certain districts.

Outside of Malaya, urban planning in colonial Singapore was orchestrated around optimisation for greater administrative gain. In H.F. Pearson’s analysis of Jackson’s Plan, the text shows British colonial powers using urban planning to implement administrative control over the settlement, though in this instance it was not exactly successful. However, the intent was always evident. The intent is especially evident in Pearson’s analysis of Jackson’s Plan, which demonstrates the ambitions of colonial planners for Singapore. Pearson cites a contemporary description of the plan: “The general plan of the town, showing the allotment of the different campongs, principal roads and streets, and the ground reserved for public purposes,”6 which shows an initial effort to make Singapore spatially ordered and, ultimately, more administratively manageable. Jackson’s Plan also included “well-regulated roads and kampongs planned according to Raffles’s instructions.”7 The language here of “well-regulated” and “planned according to Raffles’s instructions” yet again reinforces that colonial officials wanted Singapore’s physical organisation to reflect British administrative decisions.

The cases of colonial Singapore and Malaya both go to show that urban planning was not merely about creating a functional colonial settlement. Rather, urban planning was used to create a spatial organisation of a colonial settlement that was best equipped to be governable and easily regulated administratively as well as being economically efficient. The pieces of Swettenham and Pearson allow us to understand what intentions are behind the planning of a colonial city and how those intentions become realised in the actual city itself.

  1. Frank Swettenham, British Malaya: An Account of the Origin and Progress of British Influence in Malaya (London: John Lane, 1907), 238–39. [↩]
  2. Swettenham, British Malaya, 294. [↩]
  3. Swettenham, British Malaya, 295. [↩]
  4. Swettenham, British Malaya, 239. [↩]
  5. Swettenham, British Malaya, 242. [↩]
  6. H. F. Pearson, “Lt. Jackson’s Plan of Singapore,” Journal of the Malaysian Branch of Royal Asiatic Society 42. no. 1 (1969): 163, quoting Singapore Consultations, 7 February 1823. [↩]
  7. Pearson, “Lt. Jackson’s Plan of Singapore,” 164. [↩]

Mapping Illness and Spatial Division in Hong Kong

Illness, although not the first thing that might typically come to mind when discussing spatial histories, can prove very significant in mapping patterns of settlement, social divisions, and perceptions of different public spaces. “Climate and Sanitary Condition” from The Treaty Ports of China and Japan illustrates how illness intersects with the labelling of certain spaces. “Climate and Sanitary Condition” from The Treaty Ports of China and Japan describes mid-19th-century Hong Kong from the view of the foreign inhabitants residing there. This source is fascinating for a number of reasons. At first glance, this section of the source, “Climate and Sanitary Condition,” seems to focus solely on disease, specifically detailing which illnesses befell the foreigners across their first few years of inhabitance in the British colony of Hong Kong, with the primary source citing all sorts of illnesses throughout Hong Kong, corresponding locations of said illnesses and outbreaks, and a chart denoting mortality rates among foreigners in their first eight years settling in Hong Kong. However, the meticulous mapping and logging of the specific locations of illness outbreaks serve a broader purpose. By mapping illness outbreaks to certain spots in Hong Kong, the author covertly manages to forge associations, through the use of deliberate language, characterising spaces where predominantly lower-class Hong Kong locals reside as sites of illness. These associations strengthen pre-existing racial/class divisions between foreigners and Hong Kong locals under the guise of spatial divisions. This idea is further reinforced by many other sources in mid-19th century China, like in Treaty Ports in Modern China: Law, Land and Power and The Treaty Ports of China and Japan, where foreign ideas surrounding sanitation and health oftentimes informed the spatial organisation of China’s treaty ports.

The language used to map various illnesses in “Climate and Sanitary Condition” demonstrates how perceptions of disease became paired with particular spaces, and the people who resided in those spaces. “Climate and Sanitary Condition” has a section describing the foreign-stationed soldiers who were residing amongst Hong Kong locals when there was a particularly severe outbreak of an illness, the source writes, “From all accounts, it is not easy to escape the spots of this malarious character at Hong Kong; and if it is ever to be a healthy station, our soldiers must not be housed as they have been hitherto.”1 The terminology used by the author here, describing spots in Hong Kong as possessing “malarious character”2 and later in the source describing the locality of the barracks as “unwholesome,”3 illustrates a contempt for certain spots in Hong Kong, and these certain spots are far from coincidental. The foreign soldiers of the “unwholesome” locality were stationed in the barracks of the East and West ends of town, where many lower-class Hong Kong locals resided.4 In fact, most, if not all, of the “towns” where illness is mapped throughout “Climate and Sanitary Condition” were inhabited by Hong Kong locals, usually “among the lower classes.”5

Due to the large emphasis placed on mapping illness, sanitation became a big priority in areas occupied by foreigners, as a means to combat the areas marked by illness. Specific language in source passages in “Climate and Sanitary Condition” demonstrate just how much sanitation was prioritised. In Bickers and Jackson’s Treaty Ports in Modern China: Law, Land and Power, it is explained that sanitation played a big role in the organisation of foreign spaces within China’s treaty ports. Significantly, this mention of sanitation was centred in the foreign concession, again illustrating spatial separation between foreigners and locals in the treaty ports. Bickers and Jackson write that treaty-port municipal authorities in China employed “public health officials” and attempted to construct “a suitable system for sanitation in the concession.”6 An emphasis on sanitation in the foreign concession does not mean a lack of sanitation in local areas by any means; the significance here has more to do with the emphasis and importance placed on sanitation and how significant this concept was to foreigners. This illustrates that both in the treaty ports and in cities like Hong Kong, when something was deemed sanitary or needing to be sanitised, it was reliably associated with foreigners. Associative wording is of the utmost significance here, as putting so much emphasis on sanitation in foreign spaces creates a connotation of “sanitary” and “healthy” in specific relation to the foreigners. Contrasting that with the aforementioned descriptions of local spaces as “unwholesome” and having “malarious character,” there appears to be quite a harsh divide between locals and foreigners and what attributes or associations they have been given.

A large idea in aforementioned primary source passages is how certain spaces were “marked” with certain illness. Though this is evident throughout “Climate and Sanitary Condition,” it is not exclusive to Hong Kong foreigners and their perceptions of Hong Kong locals. In Henriot’s “The Shanghai Bund in Myth and History: An Essay through Textual and Visual Sources,” Henriot wrote about the renaming of Chinese street names with French figures in Shanghai’s French Concession, demonstrating that colonial separatism from Chinese locals was produced through terminology, where language was able to “mark” spaces in a way that imbues a real association with a place.7 This is arguably the same method of separatism through terminology as seen in the “Climate and Sanitary Condition” section of The Treaty Ports of China and Japan, prompting the question: was the practice of foreigners labelling or “marking” of local spaces commonplace across China in the mid-19th century? Was the practice of “marking” through language predominantly negative in connotation? Or, is this just a small sample of foreigners describing local spaces, not indicative of the opinions of the larger foreign population that inhabited China? Nevertheless, it is interesting to see the role of associative language in both Hong Kong and treaty ports in China.

Ultimately, in The Treaty Ports of China and Japan, the sections regarding illness and sanitation were as they appeared to be. The Treaty Ports of China and Japan was not useful providing empirical evidence through the logging and mapping of illnesses in mid-19th-century Hong Kong; instead, the writing on illness revealed more about the social perspectives, class divisions between Hong Kong locals and foreigners, and how language reinforced spatial separation between them.

  1. Nicholas Belfield Dennys, ed., The Treaty Ports of China and Japan: A Complete Guide to the Open Ports of Those Countries, Together with Peking, Yedo, Hongkong and Macao (London: Trübner and Co., 1867), 32. [↩]
  2. Dennys, Treaty Ports of China and Japan, 32. [↩]
  3. Dennys, Treaty Ports of China and Japan, 33. [↩]
  4. Dennys, Treaty Ports of China and Japan, 33. [↩]
  5. Dennys, Treaty Ports of China and Japan, 34. [↩]
  6. Robert Bickers and Isabella Jackson, eds., Treaty Ports in Modern China: Law, Land and Power (London: Routledge, 2016), 3. [↩]
  7. Christian Henriot, “The Shanghai Bund in Myth and History: An Essay through Textual and Visual Sources,” Journal of Modern Chinese History 4, no. 1 (2010): 5–6. [↩]