Western Influence on the Modern Japanese Home

During the Meiji period in Japan, there were many developments in the urban sphere, especially in the home. Edward S. Morse, an American observer, recorded his thoughts about Japanese housing and modernisation in his book Japanese Homes and Their Surroundings (1886). In his book, Morse writes about the architecture, arrangement, and construction of the Japanese home, while comparing them to homes in the West. Throughout Morse’s account of the Japanese home, there are comments of both admiration and criticism. It is in Morse’s criticisms that the cultural differences present between the West and Japan become clear. Morse’s account shows how Western expectations of domestic comfort and home design shaped perceptions of Japanese homes, which suggests that the modernisation of Japanese homes was not simply a wave of new innovation efforts, but was a more conscious effort of modernisation partly influenced by Western ideas.

Morse’s account features many opinions regarding the structure and contents of the Japanese home, some of which he regarded as quite admirable. Morse specifically enjoyed the craftsmanship of the Japanese home, writing, “their methods were not only the simplest and most economical, but they answered all the requirements. One is amazed to see how many firemen can gather upon such a roof without its yielding.”1 Morse had a few positive comments about the Japanese home, mostly about the structural ingenuity and architectural design of the home. However, despite any positives that Morse found, Morse had several fundamental issues with how the Japanese home was constructed, finding the Japanese home particularly deficient in privacy as well as comfort. Morse thought it uncomfortable that the divisions used in Japanese homes were primarily sliding doors or non-permanent dividers: “In the Japanese house, on the contrary, there are two or more sides that have no permanent walls.”2 Morse finds the lack of permanent walls to be a design flaw, one that contrasts with the homes in the West, which often featured multiple permanent walls and doors to shut spaces to ensure privacy. The core theme present in Morse’s account is how frequently he uses Western standards as a measure for the successful construction of a home. Morse often uses Western expectations and norms of domestic comfort, e.g., enclosed spaces and less open-concept construction. These criticisms of what Japanese homes lack in comparison to Western homes eventually become the very aspects that are incorporated into the Japanese home.

Morse’s account reflects an early stage of Japanese home modernisation, when Western ideas began to influence the Japanese home. Morse’s account can also be better understood when positioned within the broader context of Japanese housing reform and modernisation. In Jordan Sand’s House and Home in Modern Japan, he describes how several significant changes occurred in domestic environments between 1880 and 1930 (this includes Morse’s writings in the Meiji period). Sand writes, “In the final stage of the conversion, rooms gain distinct functions (significantly including a separate bedroom for the couple), floor-living is abandoned, and the ‘empty ceremony’ of traditional guest reception gives way to family leisure.”3 Sand is describing the work of a prominent Japanese modernist architect, Tanabe Junkichi. His vision of comfortable “Western-style living,” complete with functionally divided rooms, is the exact ideal that Morse found lacking in the Japanese home from before, showing the integration of Western domestic ideals eventually becoming physically present in the Japanese home.

There are several elements that the Western onlooker Edward S. Morse disliked about Japanese homes, one of which was the seating arrangement, specifically that of floor sitting. Morse states, “The sitting posture on the floor is painful…I find that our chairs are painful to the Japanese until they become accustomed to them. “4 This again proves Western influence, as down the line, domestic spaces in Japan began transitioning from floor sitting to chair sitting. In Housing in Postwar Japan, Ann Waswo writes, “the western-style, chair-sitting way of life that had been confined to the DK began to spread”5 into other areas of the home over time. Demonstrating that Western ideals eventually became incorporated into Japanese homes. Ann Waswo also explains the transition from traditional Japanese-style furnishings to the adoption of Westernised furnishings. Waswo writes, “the workshops and factories that sprang up to supply that market soon branched out into producing other items of western-style furniture.”6 The furniture production here demonstrates demand for Western-style furniture pieces, now showing that some Western ideals were not only integrated into the Japanese home, but some were even popularised.

Morse’s Japanese Homes and Their Surroundings speaks to how Western ideals began to influence certain elements in the Japanese home during the Meiji period in Japan. Morse’s account is useful as an early perspective during the start of Westernisation efforts in the Japanese home. Additionally, Morse’s admiration, as well as his criticism, reflects how Western cultural expectations eventually became physically manifested in Japanese domestic spaces. Sand’s House and Home in Modern Japan builds on Morse’s account by demonstrating how Western ideals manifested in tangible, physical changes in Japanese homes. Ann Waswo’s Housing in Postwar Japan demonstrates how this trend of Westernisation in the home extended into later time periods in Japan. All of these developments show that the modernisation of Japanese homes was not just about architectural improvements or innovations, but rather a transformation of domestic spaces that was partly influenced by Western ideals for the home.

  1. Edward S. Morse,  Japanese Homes and Their Surroundings (Boston: Ticknor and Company, 1886), 19–20. [↩]
  2. Morse,  Japanese Homes and Their Surroundings, 7. [↩]
  3.  Jordan Sand, House and Home in Modern Japan: Architecture, Domestic Space, and Bourgeois Culture, 1880–1930 (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Asia Center, 2003), 178. [↩]
  4. Morse, Japanese Homes and Their Surroundings, 12. [↩]
  5. Ann Waswo,  Housing in Postwar Japan: A Social History (Abingdon: Routledge, 2013), 93. [↩]
  6. Waswo, Housing in Postwar Japan, 73. [↩]

For an American Audience: Manchuria, Wild West of the Far East

 

Owen Lattimore was born in 1900 to English teachers, and he grew up in American settlements in China, specifically Shanghai, Baodingfu, and Beijing.1 He would go on to be an eminent sinologist. In 1929 he wrote the New York Times article, Manchuria, Wild West of the Far East.  His lived experience is reflected in his writing, “We think of China as a land to which we go by steamer, stopping off at treaty ports and living in the safety of foreign concessions.”2 In this work, he rhetorically makes Chinese settlement legible to New York Times readers through the lens of American westward expansion. He is not only engaging with the American audience, but simultaneously legitimizes the settlement of Manchuria internationally as a vehicle for progress and modernity.  However, his lack of mention of Japanese involvement in the opium trade exposes the selectivity of this narrative, revealing pitfalls in using foreign accounts as source material.

Though 20th century Manchuria was fundamentally Chinese territory, both Russia and Japan had large foreign concessions and populations due to their construction of the Chinese Eastern Railway and Southern Manchurian Railway, respectively. So much so that Lattimore writes, “A traveler going through Manchuria by rail might well think he was passing through three countries.” To an American, this means that in Changchun, you will not be met with “Chinese coolies” but rather, a “stalwart bearded, white-aproned Russian porters”, and in Mukden, a “neat Japanese Pullman porter” will lay out “Japanese slippers”. He uses service workers as a tangible way to communicate the internationality of the region.3

He connects his reporting to issues that Americans care about. The meeting of “Russia and China” in Manchuria has the potential to affect geopolitics. Unless the two countries can “come to an agreement about limits of expansion and colonization, then Manchuria will once more be the pivot of war and invasion.” Japan is mentioned throughout the article in a commercial and modern sense, their “enterprise and efficiency” is emphasized. But ironically, they are not included in the geopolitical analysis.3

The narrative established by Lattimore of railway modernity dominating over tribalism and lawlessness is undercut by his reporting on opium. He writes that “railroads and international rivalries have turned several Manchurian “rackets” into big business”. He writes that pioneers are pressured by bandits that have “universally become known as Hunghutze, or Redbeards” to grow opium, which is then “smuggled [by bandits] in every conceivable way, even in the heating pipes of passenger trains”.3 I was not able to find a source to corroborate drug deception through heating pipes. Though he is not incorrect that bandits or natives posed a serious threat to settlement, the main vehicle in Manchuria for opium and smuggling was the Japanese empire itself. A New York Times article from Feb. 14, 1919 circulated a charge that the Japanese smuggled opium into China through their control of the South Manchurian railway. Under Japanese extraterritoriality, even prior to the Manchurian Incident 1931, “no Japanese can be arrested without informing the consulate.”4 However,  this would disrupt the narrative being painted by Lattimore of railway civilization inserting itself into uncivilized lands. The railway did not simply replace the supposedly lawless frontier with an ordered, modern society, but facilitated new forms of exploitation and illicit economic activity.

The article thus falls within a large group of literature either consciously or unconsciously perpetuating colonial civilizing justifications, while being historically flawed and incomplete. For instance, the 1900s to the 1920s Japanese “bazoku” or “bandit” literature used masculine bandit figures to intellectually transform Manchuria into a Japanese frontier for conquest5. Modern ‘Kimchi Westerns’, mostly by Korean studios, such as the Good, the Bad, and the Weird (2008), and Netflix original series Song of the Bandits (2023) portray Manchuria as a lawless territory undergoing modernisation. Both heavily feature railways as avenues for this change, and to say they lack historical precision is perhaps an understatement.

 

  1. https://academic.oup.com/oxford-dictionary-of-national-biography/reference/63486/reference-article-abstract/580946462?redirectedFrom=fulltext#580946462 [↩]
  2. https://www.nytimes.com/1929/07/28/archives/manchuria-wild-west-of-the-far-east-where-russia-and-china-clash.html [↩]
  3. Ibid. [↩] [↩] [↩]
  4. https://www.nytimes.com/1919/02/14/archives/charge-that-japan-aids-opium-trade-sends-morphia-into-china-and.html [↩]
  5. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/modern-asian-studies/article/making-manchuria-japans-frontier-the-bazoku-fantasy-and-imperial-masculinity-1900s1920s/BBF0A932AEE726AC40CA3FB07DADA2A6 [↩]

Research Update — The Fall of the Lonely Island: The Shanghai International Settlement’s Experience of Japanese Occupation

My ongoing research examines how the collapse of a particular spatial and political order was experienced by the inhabitants of Shanghai’s International Settlement when Japanese occupation brought an end to decades of Western extraterritorial privilege and municipal autonomy. Shanghai’s experience of the Sino-Japanese War was distinctive in the gradual manner in which the city underwent conquest and occupation. Following Japan’s victory in the Battle of Shanghai in 1937, the Japanese occupied the Chinese-administered parts of the city, while the International Settlement and French Concession remained outside direct Japanese control. From 1937 to December 1941, these foreign-administered enclaves constituted what became known as the ‘Lonely Island’ (孤岛), where the insecurity of Japanese military encirclement coexisted with a degree of protection afforded by Western extraterritoriality. In this post, I will first introduce the rationale and methodology that underpinned the research, and then lay down some observations I have made over preliminary research.

This research focuses on how the inhabitants of the International Settlement experienced the collapse of this order following the Japanese occupation of December 1941. It focuses especially on the Western (especially Anglo-American) population who are simultaneously ‘enemy nationals’ and the long-established foreign interests in the International Settlement. For them, the takeover represented more than the loss of a major commercial centre — it disrupted an established system of municipal government, foreign privilege, and social hierarchy, with Japanese occupation exposing the fragility of a social order built upon the assumption of Western supremacy. The foreign presence, previously sustained by extraterritorial rights and the authority of the Shanghai Municipal Council (SMC), could no longer guarantee the security or privileged position of its inhabitants. The occupation was therefore a moment of both physical disruption and psychological disillusionment. Crucially, this transformation was experienced in spatial as well as political terms. The International Settlement had long embodied Western extraterritorial authority through its control over municipal institutions, public infrastructure and the regulation of urban space. Japanese occupation consequently unsettled established assumptions about who could govern, occupy and exercise authority over the city. Although existing works have examined in considerable detail how the populations of the foreign concessions experienced the years 1941–45, most remain largely narrative accounts and lack a strong analytical dimension.1 Most importantly, the occupation’s psychological and spatial ramifications in Shanghai have yet to be fully elucidated.

Hence, this research pays particular attention to how established practices and expectations surrounding public spaces, social life and municipal services were disrupted — or maintained — under the new administration. How such changes and continuities affected the mentality of Shanghai’s Western population is central to the enquiry. Beyond the existing contextual literature on wartime Shanghai, this research draws upon a diverse body of primary sources. Official records, particularly the Shanghai Municipal Police archives and Shanghai Municipal Council reports, will provide evidence of how the existing municipal authorities negotiated their position under Japanese occupation. Along with newspapers, accessible through various digital archives, these sources will also supplement the official accounts with contemporary reports and anecdotal evidence of changes in urban life.2  On a more individual level, memoirs and personal accounts written by Jewish, Western and Chinese residents of wartime Shanghai form a substantial part of the analysis, offering perspectives on how the occupation was experienced in everyday life — from lighting regulations and counter-terrorism drills to the imposition of neighbourhood surveillance and, eventually, internment.3  Regarding the spatial focus of the work, these personal testimonies also offer insights into how space was intimately perceived and experienced by residents on the ground. Taken together, these sources allow the research to connect the transformation of Shanghai’s political and municipal order with more immediate, personal experiences, thereby illustrating the profound changes to the city’s spatiality brought about by the fall of extraterritorial Shanghai. Finally, all this serves to show the various ways in which the expatriate population of Shanghai conceptualised their existence in the cosmopolitan city — as both its most prominent administrators and constructors, and a somewhat detached pseudo-colonial overclass — just as that existence was coming to an end.

Preliminary readings of numerous secondary sources and several memoirs have revealed a number of noteworthy themes. First, like the preceding gudao era, the occupation period cannot be described in absolute terms. Various scholars have questioned the term gudao in light of its inaccurate implication of the foreign settlements’ total seclusion and security, pointing to various instances in which Japanese authorities had already begun to encroach upon Anglo-American power in the concessions.4  Similarly, the period of occupation after 1941 was not immediately a doomsday scenario. Until the introduction of internment for all Allied nationals in January 1943, most Anglo-Americans — while subject to constant surveillance and occasional interrogation — were more or less able to get on with their lives. Although many businesses and institutions were placed under Japanese administration or surveillance, they did not, by any means, undergo complete deprivation. In fact, as one Chinese memoir recounts, these foreigners adopted a ‘live in the moment’ mentality: ‘When their cars were “requisitioned” by the Japanese, they turned to bicycles — pedalling out each morning to buy groceries.’5  It was not until October 1942 that they were banned from entering entertainment venues such as clubs, cinemas and racecourses.6  The takeover is therefore mediated through a balance of change and continuity. Beneath the shadow of the rising sun, the maintenance of a pseudo-normal life and the agency individuals demonstrated in the face of great adversity should not be neglected in favour of a dramatic, dichotomous narrative. The persistence of this outlook is illustrated by the fact that, even after the liberation of Shanghai, with extraterritoriality already abolished in 1943, many Anglo-Americans still dreamed of their restoration to the privileged position they had once enjoyed in a Settlement that no longer existed.7

The Japanese occupation also brought a cornucopia of spatial implications. On 8 December 1941 alone, all the buildings along the Bund — previously a showcase for Anglo-American hegemony — had to raise the Japanese flag rather than the Union Jack or the Stars and Stripes, as Japanese troops thronged the streets of the Settlement and its residents could do nothing but watch.8  In the months and years that followed, large billboards were erected to celebrate Japan’s triumphs in Southeast Asia; the streets were used to parade Allied POWs to intimidate the Anglo-Americans; and the Great War Cenotaph and statues dedicated to Anglo-American luminaries on the Bund were torn down.9  The Japanese authorities thus made a spatial declaration of the end of Anglo-American hegemony in the city, ironically presenting it as part of a move towards the decolonisation of China. This new spatial order was not merely materially constructed, but also experienced by the people who inhabited it. A telling episode occurred when the internees designated for the Pudong camp were assembled from the Puxi area and collectively transported from the Bund. We can only imagine what the Anglo-Americans might have felt as they saw the Huangpu stripped of their formidable battleships and the Bund now decorated with the flags of the rising sun, while sailing into the uncertainties of the Pudong internment camp, likely in a state of disillusionment and deep uncertainty.10  Other changes to daily life in Shanghai — especially its growing militarisation and increasing restrictions — can also be examined from a spatial perspective. The imposition of the Bao Jia system (for neighbourhood surveillance and administration), alongside lighting and electricity restrictions, altered the previous spatiality of downtown Shanghai.11  Far from being a place of unimpeded movement and constant flows of traffic and people, the city became increasingly segmented, with people constantly stopped at intersections for searches and inspections. The iconic neon lights that had illuminated Shanghai’s nightscape were eventually banned.  This signalled the end of the carefree pre-1941 nightlife. It’s curious how contemporary Shanghainese use ‘the break of day / 天亮’ to refer to an anticipated liberation — the phrase might well carry a literal (the absence of lights under Japanese occupation) as well as figurative meaning.12   Turning to the Western populations, both visually and behaviourally, the indulgent and luxurious social life enjoyed by them was suppressed by the new administration. These are all very preliminary observations, and as my research progresses, some new points will emerge, while others may be discarded or modified. Nevertheless, I am confident that I have plenty to work with. Exploring the experience of an expatriate population in a time of radical change is itself a tantalising topic, and being able to illuminate this largely forgotten chapter of history in the place where I grew up provides an additional attraction. Tortuous as the reading has been, my enthusiasm for these fascinating stories has only grown stronger.

  1. Bernard Wasserstein, Secret War in Shanghai: Treachery, Subversion and Collaboration in the Second World War (London, 2017); Greg Leck, Captives of Empire: The Japanese Internment of Allied Civilians in China 1941-1945 (Bangor, 2006 [↩]
  2. Preliminary newspapers I am planning to consult are: the North China Herald and the China Weekly Review (as the most prominent publishing organs), the Shanghai Times (a collaborationist paper), and the Shenbao (as a Chinese source) [↩]
  3. Ruth Barr and Betty Barr, Ruth’s Record: The Diary of an American in Japanese-Occupied Shanghai, 1941–1945 (Hong Kong, 2017); Juyin Tao, Gu Dao Jian Wen: Kang Zhan Shi Qi De Shang Hai (Shanghai, 1979); James Ballard, Miracles of Life: Shanghai to Shepperton, An Autobiography (London, 2008), epub. [↩]
  4. ‘Introduction’ in Christian Henriot and Wen-Hsin Yeh (eds) In the Shadow of the Rising Sun: Shanghai under Japanese Occupation (Cambridge 2004), p. 6 [↩]
  5. Tao, Gu Dao Jian Wen, p. 163 [↩]
  6. Ibid. [↩]
  7. Greg Leck, Captives of Empire, pp. 406-410. [↩]
  8. Tao, Gu Dao Jian Wen, p. 109. [↩]
  9. Ibid., pp. 153-154; Wasserstein, Secret War in Shanghai, pp. 105-106. [↩]
  10. Leck, Captives of Empire, pp. 126-127 [↩]
  11. Tao, Gu Dao Jian Wen, pp. 124-127.; Leck, Captives of Empire, pp. 74-77. [↩]
  12. Tao, Gu Dao Jian Wen, p. 124. [↩]

Dress for the Colony You Want: Colonial Dress and the Tropics

In the mid 1800s, it was a commonly believed that wearing a flannel or woolen band wrapped around the abdomen could prevent disease. This item, dubbed the ‘cholera belt’ (fig. 1), was championed as both preventative tool and a treatment for cholera from the 1830s to the 1890s. Up until the very end of the 19th century, physicians and scientists contended that diseases like malaria, cholera, and plague were spread by miasmas – noxious gasses which emanated from rotting organic matter, swamps and marshes, or general filth such as human excrement. Despite the emergence of germ theory as an alternative epidemiological approach founded upon the research of figures such as John Snow, Robert Koch, Ronald Ross, and Louis Pasteur, the miasma theory persisted residually into the early 20th century. Founded upon inaccurate medical and environmental knowledge and heavily influenced by colonial cultural ideas of tropical regions of East Asia as inherently dangerous to the European body, the cholera belt created a boundary between the colonist and the tropics, one of isolation and protection.

Figure 1. Thomas Drew, ‘Design for the Chemical Sanitary Belt and Cholera Repellant’, 1848. Courtesy of the National Archives, BT 45/9/1610.

To protect Europeans in the tropics, physicians, scientists, and medical professionals developed curious medical technologies such as the ‘cholera belt’ which supposedly shielded the body from disease by filtering air and warming the abdomen, but this quack prophylactic was an impractical defense against diseases. As is known today, cholera is spread by Vibrio Cholerae; however, despite the bacterium’s discovery by Filippo Pacini in 1854 and John Snow’s breakthrough waterborne transmission theory that same year, germ theory was not widely recognized until later research by Robert Koch in the 1880s.1 Prior to these discoveries, physicians believed that cooling the body made it more vulnerable to contracting diseases. Sweating was commonly understood to prevent disease, thus the repression of it by cool night breezes was something medical publications warned against. As one 1803 treatise remarks, cooling of the body “is always followed by a feverish dry skin, owing to a stoppage of perspiration, and very often proves a cause of violent diseases”.2 By the 1820s, medical texts advised people to “wear a flannel waistcoat or flannel bandage around [one’s] loins and abdomen, and avoid exposure to the night-dews and fogs” to protect against cholera.3 On and off, the cholera belt was required by British Army clothing regulations.The 1874 Sungie-Ujong and 1875 Perak expeditions in Malaysia listed cholera belts (sometimes two to each man) as official dress for the tropical campaigns.4 Woolen and flannel products continued to be advertised as “[protection] from disease” (fig. 2) as late as the 1890s. However, by the turn of the century, medical authorities and soldiers alike reported unanimously that “body bands did not contribute either to comfort, warmth or health…Ultimately, in 1917…their issue ceased”.5 The cholera belt could not protect the colonist, and medical and scientific professionals finally abandoned the garment.

Figure 2. ‘Dr Jaeger’s Sanitary Woollen System’, The Strand Magazine 1:2 (London, 1891), p. iv.

The cholera belt’s prolonged use into the 20th century is indebted to the failure of colonial hygienists and physicians to distinguish between the dangers of tropical climates and that of tropical diseases. David Arnold outlines that the sweeping fluctuations of temperature, high humidity, and intense sunlight common to many tropical countries were thought to “[weaken] the constitutions of Europeans who were not designed for, or adapted to, warm climates”. 6 Under most circumstances, traveling to the tropics was deadly for Europeans. In the 19th century, death rates for Europeans in tropical regions were more than double that at home (fig. 3).7 Epidemiologically, moving troops to new environments will expose them to diseases they have not developed immunities for, but many contemporary Europeans understood this phenomenon to signify the “danger of a ‘tropical climate'” rather than the danger of tropical diseases.8

Figure 3. Mortality of European Troops at Home and Abroad, 1817-38. Curtin, Death by Migration, p. 11.

As the work of Snow, Koch, Ross, and others advanced epidemiological understandings of tropical diseases toward an acceptance of germ theory, conceptions of the tropical climate as specifically hostile to Europeans were subdued. Although the cholera belt did not live up to its prophylactic objectives. it had been instrumental in perpetuating colonial understandings and experiences of the tropics as dangerous. Its decline was a small step in a much larger process of deepening understandings of the environment, medicine, and health in the colonial era.

  1. David Arnold (ed.), Warm Climates and Western Medicine: The Emergence of Tropical Medicine, c. 1500-1900 (Amsterdam, 1996), p. 150. [↩]
  2. Thomas Masterman Winterbottom, Medical Directions for the Use of Navigators and Settlers in Hot Climates (London, 1803), p. 9. [↩]
  3. James Annesley, Researches into the Causes, Nature, and Treatment of the More Prevalent Diseases of India, and of Warm Climates Generally, vol. 2 (London, 1828), p. 403. [↩]
  4. Andrew Duncan, The Prevention of Disease in Tropical and Sub-tropical Campaigns (London, 1888), p. 36. [↩]
  5. W. G. Macpherson, W. H. Horrocks, and William W. O. Beveridge (eds), Medical Services: Hygiene of the War, vol. 1 (London, 1923), p. 314. [↩]
  6. Arnold, Warm Climates and Western Medicine , p. 183. [↩]
  7. Philip D. Curtin, Death by Migration: Europe’s Encounter with the Tropical World in the Nineteenth Century (Cambridge, 1989), p. 1, 11. [↩]
  8. Ibid., p. 12. [↩]

Get the Picture?: Images of Kampongs in the Dutch East Indies, 1910-1911

How does a photograph become an instrument of social reform? In documentary photography, shots are characterized as neutral, objective, and truthful, but visuals carry narratives just as texts do. After settling in the Dutch East Indies in 1896, Dutch pharmacist and entrepreneur H.F. Tillema (1870-1952) turned his camera toward the kampongs of Semarang, a major port city, calling attention to links between unsanitary housing conditions and deadly epidemics. Lacking effective sewage drainage, these densely populated water-based dwellings deteriorated into slums where disease like cholera, typhoid, and dysentery proliferated. Dutch historian K.M. van Roosmalen remarks that Tillema’s photography was not a hobby, but instead was intended to motivate public health reform.1 Tillema’s photographs challenged colonial authorities to confront inadequacies of public health infrastructure in these communities, but also embodied an objectified view of Malay people.

Featured alongside statistics and maps, his photographs of the urban environment demonstrated the troubling relationship between urban planning and public health in Semarang and the need for sanitary infrastructural improvements. Due to poor drainage systems, urban kampongs flooded frequently. Even after weeks of drought, stagnant water accumulated, providing the perfect breeding grounds for infectious diseases. Unsettled by disproportionately high infection rates among kampong residents, Tillema compiled a study, Riooliana (Sewage), in which he argued that, although expensive, constructing a modern sewage system, establishing sanitary water supply systems, and educating the public on hygienic standards and practices were together crucial for combating infectious diseases.2 Two years later, he curated a second, larger study on living conditions in Semarang and pointedly sent it to colonial administrators in the Dutch East Indies.3 Throughout the next decade, at his own expense, he printed and mailed thousands of pages and six volumes of his research and photographs to executive and legislative authorities in both the Netherlands and the Dutch East Indies.

Figure 1. H.F. Tillema, ‘Flooding in a street in a kampong’, ca. 1910, Semarang. Courtesy of Wereld Museum, RV-A440-aa-183.

The cultural and fiscal context of Tillema’s Dutch origins and colonial ties adds a metaphorical distance to scenes of huddled families in muddy streets (fig. 1). Ideologically, his studies carry residues of European colonial assumptions that Asian populations were culturally predisposed to unsanitary habits. Although he advocated for infrastructural improvements on behalf of Malay residents, he did this in part because he believed the ‘civilizing mission’ concept that needed to be advocated for:

“Since the population is so uneducated and consequently so superstitious, considerable difficulties are encountered when implementing hygienic measures. At times, the population rises up and becomes resistant, as I believe happened in Bandoeng [Bandung].” H.F. Tillema, Kromoblanda (The Hague, 1915-1923), p. 45.

Moreover, Tillema held positions of both fiscal and administrative power, providing resources to fund his photography and the authority to confront colonial policy makers. Owing to Hygeia, his bottled mineral water company, Tillema financially benefited from the lack of safe drinking water since his product as a safe alternative to the unsanitary well-water.4 His fortune led him to be elected a member of the Semarang Municipal Council in 1910. In this context, human subjects in Tillema’s photographs, staring absently from their flooded homes (fig. 1), off-center in their own composition, are not the focus; rather, they are simply another statistical component of his study.

These images capitalize on the view of indigenous populations as in need of colonial intervention, effectively framing them as ‘other’. In this colonial gaze, figures become part of the landscape. In one photograph, residents stand still in contrast to the blurred motion of the duck in the foreground (fig. 1). Their immobility symbolizes inaction and reflects Tillema’s assumption that Malay people were indifferent to their unsanitary environments and uninterested in taking action to learn new hygiene practices. In another example, Tillema photographed a child defecating (fig. 2) to illustrate the insufficiency of public health amenities, but in the process committed a gross infringement upon the subject’s privacy and humanity; the child is here defined solely by his unsanitary practices. The Malay subjects of Tillema’s photography are characterized as complacent in their filth, thus necessitating colonial sanitation programs.

Figure 2. H.F. Tillema, ‘Public W.C. in Kampong Randoesari’, ca. 1910, in Riooliana, p. 10.

The Dutch East Indies Malay population was also objectified and disregarded by the colonial administration. Van Roosmalen specifies that the Malay people were dismissed as ambivalent to colonial urban planning policies.5 In reality, widespread illiteracy hampered Malay civic participation. Lacking a line of communication to voice their objections, indigenous peoples and lower classes were fundamentally absent from colonial authorities’ conceptions of urban communities.

Paradoxically, Tillema’s photographs also advocated for these disenfranchised communities, despite their derogatory characterizations of kampong residents and Tillema’s own ties to colonial power. His depictions of kampongs fall into the school of ‘social photography’ exemplified by American photographer Jacob Riis (1849-1914) (fig. 3).6 This genre of photography, “designed to appeal to the sympathies of the viewers”, seeks to advocate for marginalized communities by highlighting systemic injustices7 Tillema’s scenes of squalor challenged the romanticized aesthetic of the colonial era as tempo doeloe – the ‘glory days’.4 Through these photos, a centralized colonial government detached from local experiences was confronted by the needs of its public. Ultimately, sanitation systems in urban kampongs were modernized due to fears that kampongs would birth a communist uprising.8 Nevertheless, Tillema’s photographs are vivid testimonies of life, revealing details which city plans and maps fail to encapsulate. One sees streets from the perspective of people living there rather than the bird’s-eye viewpoint of urban planners. Although his photographs did not give full autonomy to Malay residents pictured, they did urge colonial officials and urban planners to see not only streets, but those who walked in them. H.F. Tillema’s photos of Semarang emphasize the necessity to examine visual historical sources as contextually ramified.

Figure 3. Jacob Riis, ‘A Mulberry Bend Alley’, ca. 1888-1889. International Center of Photography, 265.1982.

 

  1. Pauline K.M. van Roosmalen, ‘Netherlands Indies Town Planning: An Agent of Modernization (1905-1957)’, in Freek Colombijn and Joost Coté (eds), Cars, Conduits, and Kampongs: The Modernization of the Indonesian City, 1920-1960 (Leiden, 2015), p. 94. [↩]
  2. Hendrik Freerk Tillema, Riooliana (Semarang, 1911), p. 13. [↩]
  3. E. Vanvugt, ‘Tillema, Hendrik Freerk (1870-1952)’, Biographical Dictionary of the Netherlands, 12 November 2013, <http://resources.huygens.knaw.nl/bwn1880-2000/lemmata/bwn5/tillema> [accessed 8 October 2026]. [↩]
  4. Vanvugt, ‘Tillema’. [↩] [↩]
  5. van Roosmalen, ‘Netherlands Indies Town Planning’, p. 93. [↩]
  6. In striking parallel to Tillema, Riis employed photography to drive legislative and social reform for the residents of New Yory City’s horrifically overcrowded tenements. [↩]
  7. Peter Burke, Eyewitnessing: The Uses of Images as Historical Evidence (London, 2001), p. 22. [↩]
  8. van Roosmalen, ‘Netherlands Indies Town Planning’, pp. 95-96. [↩]

Sanitation & Colonial Rule in Manila (1903–1904)

The Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health describes sanitation and disease in the urban environment of Manila from September 1903 to August 1904. During this time, Manila (as well as other areas in the Philippines) had been battling the bubonic plague, an epidemic that took place under American colonial rule. The Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health was therefore written by the American colonial authorities and presents public health interventions they implemented during the years of the plague outbreak. The report reveals many things about the American colonial perspective, particularly how important sanitation measures became, and how sanitation became associated with economic growth and prosperity, racial distinctions, and colonial governance. Ultimately, this report demonstrates that American officials viewed sanitation not only as a means of preventing disease, but also as an important tool for regulating urban spaces and the local population in those spaces.

This report reveals a significant connection between sanitation and economic growth. The Commissioner in the report stresses that while sanitation is clearly a humanitarian issue at heart, it should also be valued for economic reasons, arguing that public health investments would later on produce great financial returns.1 This section of the report is most interesting, as it tries to convey that putting time, effort, money, and resources into sanitation is necessary for a number of reasons, not merely the more obvious health risks/issues associated with poor sanitation practices. This section of the report also reveals the motivations behind which issues the colonial administration chooses to prioritise, because the report very clearly connects sanitary efficiency with the prosperity of the Philippines, which also serves as a testament to the success of the American administration overseeing it.2 Because of this, sanitation becomes an issue of high importance.

Aside from economics, the relationship between sanitation and colonial authority/administration is an important theme across many colonial territories, like that of colonial Singapore for example. The Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health and Brenda Yeoh’s examination of municipal sanitary surveillance in colonial Singapore have some significant overlaps that speak to colonial administrations and their aims and wishes for their territories. In Yeoh’s piece, Yeoh describes how the British authorities used sanitation and sanitary regulations to exert control over urban spaces in Singapore, which frequently disrupted already established practices among Asian inhabitants living there.3 The American authorities in Manila, as observed in the Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health, much like in Singapore, used sanitation as a way to expand government intervention into everyday/public life. As Yeoh argues, the regulation of sanitation played a key role in shaping the power dynamic between the colonial authorities and the populations they governed. (Yeoh, Contesting Space in Colonial Singapore, 102 )) Thus, both in colonial Singapore and Manila, sanitation served as an excuse to intervene and regulate daily life.

The Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health also provides important insight into social/racial distinctions prevalent in colonial Manila at the time (1903–1904). In the report, there is an examination of mortality statistics, comparing the death rates across different racial and national groups. There are several noticeable disparities in these statistics. The data provided shows that there were significantly higher death rates among the Filipino population than among the American colonists. The data also shows that certain districts were associated with different social and racial populations.4 Although these statistics are meant to reveal differences in mortality, the report reveals how disease was understood within the frameworks of certain pre-existing race/class hierarchies. This is evident through the mention of certain urban districts and how they were perceived as particularly unhealthy, while conditions contributing to disease were interpreted through the characteristics of their inhabitants. The report observes that districts with larger Chinese populations experienced lower mortality rates than those inhabited by the “poorer class of natives.”4 This quote demonstrates how American authorities interpreted patterns of disease, that is, through their existing racial and socioeconomic divisions, associating particular urban spaces with the populations inhabiting them.

These social and racial distinctions can be better understood in Colonial Pathologies by Warwick Anderson. In Colonial Pathologies, Anderson explains that the framework for American tropical medicine in the Philippines was shaped by racial assumptions and biased colonial ideas about hygiene and civilisation.5 The Commissioner’s language in the Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health is also reflective of this broader relationship between American medical knowledge and colonial authority. By discrediting Filipino practices and classifying them as insufficiently scientific, American officials could then justify more American intervention into local communities under the guise of helping the more “ill-informed” Filipinos. This here is an example of how the medical, administrative, and sanitary practices enforced by the American colonial authority in Manila all reinforced the supposed superiority of Western ideas.

The Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health is reflective of how colonial administrations and their regulations in Manila were concerned with far more than disease prevention in their sanitation efforts. By associating sanitation with economic prosperity, public health interventions became a high priority and, perhaps more importantly, a marker of the American administration’s success and legitimacy. It is no wonder sanitation and public health intervention measures became of the utmost importance during the plague outbreak. In many ways, sanitation efforts became a way to assert power over local Filipinos. Dismissing any Filipino opposition to colonial rule, as well as disregarding their medical practices, was justified through a composed colonial hierarchy where Filipinos fell beneath American colonists. The Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health shows just how vital a tool sanitation efforts came to be for keeping the control in the hands of the American administration.

  1. Bureau of Public Health, Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health, September 1, 1903, to August 31, 1904 (Manila: Bureau of Public Printing, 1905), 7–8. [↩]
  2. Bureau of Public Health, Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health, 8. [↩]
  3. Brenda, S. A. Yeoh, Contesting Space in Colonial Singapore: Power Relations and the Urban Built Environment (Singapore: Singapore University Press, 2003), 102–104. [↩]
  4. Bureau of Public Health, Annual Report of the Commissioner of Public Health, 11-12 [↩] [↩]
  5. Warwick Anderson, Colonial Pathologies: American Tropical Medicine, Race, and Hygiene in the Philippines (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2006), 132–133. [↩]

The fate of a Shanghai sanitarium and the subtleties of spatial-hygienic imagination

Browsing through the Shanghai Municipal Police Archive with an eye to materials related to health and hygiene, and influenced by my ongoing research interest in Shanghai during the Second Sino-Japanese War, I decided to zoom in on the Archive’s dedicated sections concerning the period of Japanese occupation in Shanghai. And I came across an interesting Special Branch report on the fate of a Chinese-owned sanitarium in 1939.1 In the aftermath of the Japanese takeover of Shanghai, a sanitarium owned by the Chinese doctor Ting Wei Kong at No. 310 Hongqiao Road underwent a change in proprietorship. Located outside the International Settlement and the French Concession, which were exempt from Japanese occupation, Dr Kong leased the original premises to an Italian doctor, Dr Muto-Nardone, while the institution itself was relocated to No. 990–992 Foch Avenue in the French Concession. Perhaps to obviate Japanese suspicion regarding the legality of the lease, the contract was made to appear as though the lease had taken place ‘before the hostilities’. Dr Muto-Nardone, despite never occupying the house or taking a single penny in rent, flew the Italian flag from the premises so that it would not be occupied by the Japanese. While a Russian proposal to take over the sanitarium in July fell through because of Japanese prohibitions on patients being taken to the premises, in September the lease was transferred to the Italian Consulate after Dr Muto-Nardone moved to Switzerland to attend to his ill children. By the time the report was compiled in December, the Japanese had struck a deal with the Italian Consulate to take over the sanitarium in exchange for payment. The anecdote of this sanitarium on Hongqiao Road forms an interesting conversation with the works of various authors who have addressed the idea of hygiene and its relationship with space. Specifically, it complicates the close identification of colonial administrative space with hygienic excellence, as illustrated by the existence of hygienic institutions outside Shanghai’s foreign concessions.

In the Asian — and very often colonial — context, conceptions of cleanliness, health, and hygiene were heavily regulated by colonial authorities and therefore conceptualised through frameworks of racial categorisation and spatial segregation. More specifically, white populations and the areas inhabited by them were often privileged in hygienic policies and imagined as spaces of modernity, civility, and cleanliness. In contrast, native quarters were characterised as filthy hotbeds of disease, while their populations were deemed inexorably retrograde, impervious to civilised reasoning, and incapable of hygienic behaviour. The idea of hygiene, far from being a neutral and innocent enterprise of progress, was closely bound up with racialised colonial thinking and the racially skewed spatiality that it produced. In the case of Singapore, Asian communities were stigmatised by colonial authorities as the prime culprits in spreading zymotic diseases because of their supposedly savage and unhygienic behaviours.2 The Chinese, in particular, were castigated for their habits of huddling together and promiscuous spitting, while the dense neighbourhoods of Chinatown—characterised by overcrowding and inadequate ventilation—became an anathema to colonial hygienic sensibilities. A similar spatial-hygienic conceptualisation manifests itself even more lucidly in the French Indochinese city of Hanoi, where the stark juxtaposition between the European and indigenous quarters of the colonial city came to be seen as one of the most powerful proofs of France’s mission civilisatrice. As Michael Vann vividly puts it, ‘With its wide avenues lined with shady trees, large and luxurious villas with ample rooms, and regular—even stiflingly rigid—grid structure, the white (or European or French) quarter stood as a contrasting example of modernity in the face of the dirty, overcrowded, and backward native quarter, the Vietnamese neighbourhood of the Thirty-Six Streets’.3 Hence, as Vann traced later in his work, the enormous backlash when rats came to be discovered in the fine European sanctuaries in Hanoi.4 What we can take from the cases of Singapore and Hanoi is that conceptions of hygiene and colonial space corresponded closely with one another. European quarters were characterised by clean streets, healthy environments, and, above all, an adherence to hygienic sensibilities and behaviours; indigenous quarters, on the other hand, represented their antithetical opposite, characterised by a lack, or even absence, of health and hygiene. While not a full-fledged colony like Hanoi and Singapore, Shanghai was nevertheless a city characterised by extraterritoriality and a pseudo-colonial social hierarchy. The apparent lack of direct colonial authority should not blind us to ‘an entire social system and lifestyle that came to East Asia’, one characterised by social and commercial hegemony and a privileged foreign presence.5 It might therefore appear attractive to apply a similar spatial-hygienic framework to Shanghai: supposedly, the concessions represented spaces of superiority and cleanliness, while indigenous Shanghai represented a space of backwardness and ill health.

Yet it is important to bear in mind that a dichotomous spatial-hygienic conception — conveying a sense of complete segregation between the two — is an impartial one, complicated as it was by porous interaction in reality. In her work on Singapore, Brenda Yeoh details British efforts to regulate hygiene in indigenous quarters, first through hygienic surveillance and later through more systematic reconstruction, over the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. This testifies at least to a British awareness of the need to regulate hygiene in indigenous quarters, regardless of what their motives might have been or whether they were ultimately successful.6 The story of the Hongqiao Sanitarium in Shanghai tells an alternative but related tale. The very fact that there was a sanitarium outside the French Concession and International Settlement, and that it was owned by a Chinese doctor acknowledged as such by the Special Branch, is telling. While the report does not speak to the size or nature of the sanitarium, its subsequent relocation to the heart of the French Concession is suggestive: the sanitarium may have been quite sizeable, while its owner, Dr Ting, may have been well connected with foreign medical personnel or institutions, enabling the sanitarium to relocate to the French Concession and the premises to be leased to an Italian doctor. While perhaps not trumpeting it, this case complicates the spatial-hygienic segregation that the cases of Singapore and, to a greater extent, Hanoi might suggest. Just as British hygienic initiatives in Singapore penetrated the imagined boundaries of hygiene, the Hongqiao Sanitarium offers evidence of how health and hygiene might not have been strictly confined to areas of foreign presence in Shanghai. It has to be noted, however, that a great deal of ambiguity persists in this case. We do not yet know Dr Ting’s background, nor do we know whether the sanitarium was a strictly Chinese or a joint Sino-Western enterprise. I also need to acquire a fuller picture of the specific spatial-hygienic imagination—or imaginations—that developed in Shanghai under circumstances similar to, yet distinct from, those of Singapore and Hanoi. This does not, however, detract from the value of the source. Rather, it provides an interesting perspective on the conceptions of hygiene and space in an Asian (pseudo-)colonial setting.

  1. Shanghai Municipal Police Archive, 9599[C], ‘Hungjao Sanitarium – taken over by Japanese Military’, 15 December 1939, Roll 59. [↩]
  2. Brenda Yoh, Contesting Space in Colonial Singapore: Power Relations and the Urban Built Environment (Singapore, 2003), pp. 90-101 [↩]
  3. Michael Vann, ‘Of Rats, Rice, and Race: The Great Hanoi Rat Massacre, an Episode in French Colonial History’, French Colonial History, 4 (2003), p. 192. [↩]
  4. Ibid., pp. 195-196. [↩]
  5. Jeremy Taylor, ‘The Bund: Littoral Space of Empire in the Treaty Ports of East Asia’, Social History, 27:2 (2002), p. 125. [↩]
  6. Yoh, Contesting Space in Colonial Singapore, pp. 123-125. [↩]

“So typical of the East”: Analysis of a Chinese Physician’s Memoir

In the 19th and 20th century, shifting sanitation responsibilities led to an extension of colonial space. As explored by Brenda Yoeh, in this sense, administrators become Foucultian “specialists of space”, as they negotiate displacement, hygiene, and co-existence between peoples.1 In the case of the Manchurian plague, preservation of health ceased to be an individual care, and moved into the sphere of international concern. Dr. Wu Lien-teh’s 1959 memoir, Plague Fighter: The Autobiography of a Modern Chinese Physician, offers an in-depth glimpse into attitudes towards sanitation during the Manchurian Plague outbreak of 1910-11. Sanitary discourse of the period was not a simple divide between Western and Chinese medical populations, but rather, strongly impacted by those carrying dual identities, being simultaneously West and the Rest. 

Dr. Wu Lien-teh’s background complicates the distinction between ‘Western’ and ‘Chinese’ medical authority. He was born in Penang, British Malaya in 1879, and became the first Chinese descendant to attend Cambridge. 2 He describes himself as “Chinese”, specifically Cantonese from Sin-ning,3 Dr. Wu was a product of the medical hierarchy of his era, and often dismissed the agency and humanity of the Chinese laborers he was meant to represent. He is not a representative for all Chinese doctors of the period, but provides an example of Western ideologies bleeding into medical procedure and verbiage of the time. 

Dr. Wu’s descriptions of Chinese laborers reproduce negative psychological stereotypes. Of the Chinese laborers who had potentially been exposed to the plague, he reported an “apathy or a fatalism, so typical of the east”4 He does not acknowledge that their agency is being stripped from them in forceful quarantine. Rather, he describes them as simply giving up. When faced by a plague that has wiped out villages, and has a “100%” casualty rate,5 fatalism appears to be a perfectly rational emotional reaction. Dr. Wu is transforming a normal psychological reaction into a negative reflection on the region as a whole. 

Dr. Wu holds Chinese medical practices to contradictory standards. In reference to simple acts of sweeping and cleansing homes, he states that “the less-educated peoples of Asia had great, if ill-founded, faith in such measures during epidemics.”6 The dismissal of Chinese attempts to maintain cleanliness and order in their homes is made ironic when paired with the contemporary medical rhetoric blaming the Chinese for the ‘filth’ of their living.7 Dr. Wu espouses that a less-than-pristine hospital resembled the “corner of old backward China.” He criticizes it for “abundance of cobwebs”, and chairs that had not been “dusted for days.”8 Though he acknowledges that such measures were ‘ineffectual’ against stopping plague, he still demonizes the Chinese hospital for its backwardness, and yet cites cleaning measures as evidence of a less ‘advanced’ cultural psyche. His account simultaneously condemns cleanliness in the face of plague as irrational, while pointing to neglected spaces as evidence of inferior medical treatment. 

Dr. Wu’s adoption of imperial attitudes towards the Chinese laborers affected by the plague was not monolithic within Western educated Chinese doctors. Western medical education did not necessarily lead to acceptance of Western medical hegemony. Dr. Ho Kai, a prominent figure in fighting the plague in Hong Kong at the end of the 19th century was educated at Aberdeen University, and yet remained a strong advocate of the Chinese community in Hong Kong. He criticized the recommended burning of Chinese neighborhoods, and the forced isolation of them in hospital ships.9 Western medical training could coexist with a commitment to Chinese interests. 

Plague Fighter: The Autobiography of a Modern Chinese Physician, complicates supposed power relations between Western medical authorities and Chinese subjects. Dr. Wu’s descriptions of laborers as fatalistic and of his country as backward reveal the extent that these attitudes permeated medical discourse. He frequently adopts frameworks used to judge the Chinese population, and their actions as ‘typical of the East’ as a whole. A brief comparison to Ho Kai reveals that this attitude was not inevitable, and that Western educated Chinese doctors occupied varying realms of Western hegemony vs. Chinese advocacy. Boundaries between Western and Chinese medical thought were not simply defined along national or racial lines, but muddled by pervasive imperial dogma. The distinction between East and West in Dr. Wu’s memoir is not simply geographical, but ideological. 

  1. Yeoh, Brenda S. A. 2003. Contesting Space in Colonial Singapore. NUS Press. 86 [↩]
  2. Elle, Ning. 2015. “Remembering ‘Plague Fighter’ Dr Wu Lien-Teh.” Saw Swee Hock School of Public Health, January 16. https://sph.nus.edu.sg/news/remembering-plague-fighter-dr-wu-lien-teh [↩]
  3. Wu, Liande. 1959. Plague Fighter: The Autobiography of a Modern Chinese Physician. Cambridge: W. Heffer & Sons Ltd. 7 )) as well as a “British subject”. (( Ibid. 15 [↩]
  4. Ibid. 18 [↩]
  5. Ibid. 27 [↩]
  6. Ibid 13 [↩]
  7. Sutphen, Mary. “Not What, but Where: Bubonic Plague and the Reception of Germ Theories in Hong Kong and Calcutta, 1894–1897.” Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences 52, no. 1 (1997): 81–113. https://www.jstor.org/stable/24624205. [↩]
  8. Wu, 1959 8 [↩]
  9. Sutphen, 1997 [↩]

Tropicality in Joseph Dalton Hooker’s Himalayan Journals

Himalayan Journals, written in the year 1854, provides insight into how tropicality was observed and interpreted in South Asia, specifically India, through the lens of foreign travellers. The author of Himalayan Journals, Joseph Dalton Hooker, a naturalist and botanist, explores Darjeeling in India. Hooker describes Darjeeling as its own separate haven within India, an environmental refuge of sorts, from other areas in India that had an “unhealthy” climate (like that of the Indian plains). Hooker’s Himalayan Journals provides a closer look into colonial perspectives regarding nineteenth-century India. Hooker’s Himalayan Journals demonstrates that British colonisers dissected India, divvying up colonial Indian territories into certain sections, with each section categorised into different climatic spaces, with climatic spaces being attached to ideas about health, race, and social organisation. Hooker’s Himalayan Journals uses tropicality and environmental conditions in India to categorise which parts of India were dangerous tropical India, versus a temperate, healthy India suitable for European settlement.

As a British botanist, Hooker, in writing Himalayan Journals, shows a thorough knowledge of flora and fauna, weather and climate, and geography. Within Hooker’s account of climate, longstanding British understandings and prejudices about South Asia are also present, particularly through his descriptions of the climate and environment. Hooker first states that in order for Europeans to feel comfortable settling in the British Indian colony, they would need to be assured that the climate was temperate. Hooker writes, “the health of Europeans may be recruited by a more temperate climate.”1 This idea is present throughout Hooker’s writing. While Hooker describes Darjeeling itself, he more frequently focuses on how Darjeeling affects the Europeans inhabiting it. Hooker asserts that statistical data showed “the value of the climate to Europeans suffering from acute diseases” and argues that European troops arriving in Bengal should not be sent to Calcutta, but instead should be sent to Darjeeling.2 Hooker’s racial prejudices become most apparent when describing Europeans leaving the Indian plains as “sickly, pallid or yellow, soft and flabby.”3 This line of thought is consistent with Hippocrates’ argument that differences between populations could be explained through their environments. The understanding is that climate, seasonal variation, and geographical location are all influences capable of shaping human health.4 With this understanding also comes the understanding that certain bodies are better suited to certain environments and that movement between different climates can produce illness, further solidifying this significance as well as the distinction between tropical and temperate spaces.

While the idea that tropical versus temperate spaces could have different effects on one’s health held some merit in certain ways, Hooker’s efforts to repeatedly demonstrate distinctions between these spaces in Himalayan Journals also reflected biases. David Arnold asserts that nineteenth-century European travellers writing about India frequently constructed India as a more “tropical” other world. This act of exoticising and overemphasising the “tropicality” of the colonial territories was a commonality amongst many European literary works. The illustration of colonial territories, including those in India, as overly “tropical” and possessing wildly differing climates was often attached to or associated with negative connotations, like, for example, describing a colonial territory’s climate as being “unhealthy.” Contrastingly, the European authors referred to the climate of European countries as the more ideal temperate climate.5 Hooker’s account illustrates this through his description of the plains; instead of it being tropical, it is dangerously so, but the elevated spaces in India are described as being fitting for European settlement.

The division of climatic spaces reveals racial biases present at the time. In Hooker’s account, he writes, “Natives of the low country, and especially Bengalees, are far from enjoying the climate as Europeans do”; later, Hooker claims that their susceptibility to illness was due to their cultural practices, like those of clothing, diet, and sleep habits.3 Climatic differences then become intertwined with racial distinctions, distinctions that often carry certain negative connotations. Jiat-Hwee Chang’s analysis of tropical architecture examines this distinction as well. Chang argues that the “tropics” should not be understood as a neutral or objective climatic category. Chang writes that this is due to colonial understanding, or rather a lack of understanding, of tropical nature, where racial assumptions, medical knowledge, and practices of governance all interfere with creating an objective picture of tropicality in colonial territories6 Hooker’s description of Darjeeling is demonstrative of this, when certain climates only become a colonial concern or are deemed “unhealthy” or uninhabitable as soon as they affect the Europeans inhabiting them.

Hooker’s account in Himalayan Journals is a prime example of nineteenth-century thinking about the relationship between climate and social/racial groupings. Darjeeling as a space in Hooker’s account becomes this exception, an isolated space, as opposed to the other unfavourable climates in India (like that of the tropical plains). Descriptions of Darjeeling as elevated, not low, temperate, not tropical, give insight into what exactly foreigners viewed as a liveable environment. Hooker’s insight, combined with the context of thinkers like Hippocrates, further supports this spatial division, describing the importance of different peoples and their unique climatic needs. Again, this understanding is supposedly about climate, but more closely corresponds with race/social groups, as each race or group of people is blank. Writings such as Hooker’s demonstrate the creation of a colonial geography where certain spaces or environments were assigned a different racial or medical meaning to it.

  1. Joseph Dalton Hooker Himalayan Journals, vol. 1 (London: John Murray, 1854), 115. [↩]
  2. Hooker, Himalayan Journals, vol. I, 119. [↩]
  3. Hooker, Himalayan Journals, 1:120. [↩] [↩]
  4. Hippocrates, Airs, Waters, Places, XII-XVI, in Hippocrates vol. 1, trans. W. H. S. Jones (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1923), 106–17. [↩]
  5. David Arnold, The Tropics and the Traveling Gaze: India, Landscape, and Science, 1800–1856 (Seattle: University of Washington Press, 2006), 42–54, 110–15. [↩]
  6. Jiat-Hwee Chang, A Genealogy of Tropical Architecture: Colonial Networks, Nature and Technoscience (London: Routledge, 2016), 5–10. [↩]

‘Scotsmen the world over will be united’: The Caledonian Ball and the making of ‘Scottish’ Space in Asia

In an article present as a letter entitled ‘To Friends Across the Sea’ published in Social Shanghai, a contributor writing under the name Dulcie expressed her disappointment with the 1911 celebrations of St. George’s Day. ‘This year they decided to have a dinner,’ she complained, ‘which is considered the last resort of any patriotic Society, as it is a lazy and feeble way of displaying patriotism.’1 For the author, this event was particularly disappointing when measured against the achievements of the ‘Scotch Society’, whose Caledonian Ball, she observed, ‘never has less than a thousand guests and have had as many as fourteen hundred’. 2 Indeed, organised by the St. Andrew’s Society, Caledonian Ball was a prominent annual fixture of Shanghai’s International Settlement, and was described by a 1907 contributor to the same magazine as ‘the premier social function of the year’.3

Of course, such assessments must be read as editorial interventions. The pages of Social Shanghai were filled, if not by design, then by default, with efforts to emphasise the importance, centrality and success of whichever of the multitude of clubs, organisations and societies to which the contributor belonged. Whether or not the Scottish association occupied a particularly prominent place within Shanghai’s social hierarchy, is therefore less significant than understanding the Caledonian Ball as an example of the ways in which colonial communities constructed and maintained a sense of collective identity and belonging.

Existing scholarship has explored the particular representation and appeal of ‘Scottishness’ and Scottish national identity in the context of imperial politics, the administration of the British Empire and its aesthetic appeal within fin-de-siecle colonial society. 4 Other studies have examined the social functions of such events within colonial communities, highlighting their roles as expressions of national pride, occasions for networking among colonial elites, opportunities to fundraise for the society and its philanthropic work, and, not least, entertainment. 5 While the Caledonian Ball undoubtedly fulfilled these various functions, it also offers an opportunity to consider how such celebrations actively transformed colonial space, creating temporary environments through which participants could articulate and experience their connections to both Scotland and the wider British Empire.

Through the annual assembly of recognisable symbols, rituals and aesthetics, Shanghai’s Town Hall was temporarily transformed into a recognisably ‘Scottish’ space. Contemporary accounts of the Ball repeatedly describe a ‘familiar’ ensemble of decorations: clan shields, red and yellow drapery representing the Royal Standard, and the St Andrew’s Cross displayed alongside the Union Jack.6 A portrait of Robert Burns ‘reigned supreme’ above the central mantelpiece, while tartan and thistles featured throughout the hall. 7 Flowers and foliage were complemented by decorative weaponry, ranging from battle-axes to bayonets.8 One account even describes a display of Cairngorm rocks, Jura peat and heather shipped from Inverness, whose textures and scents evoked something of the Scottish landscape for those assembled. 9

Crucially, however, this transformation neither depended upon nor sought to produce an accurate reproduction of Scotland. As Kim Sullivan highlights, the Ball’s central imagery drew heavily upon distinctive Highland cultures, despite most Scots in Shanghai originating from the Lowlands. 10 The prominence of palm and bamboo within the hall’s decorations further underlines this distinction.11 Rather than attempting to recreate Scotland faithfully, the organisers assembled a selective and readily recognisable version of ‘Scottishness’, drawing upon symbols whose significance lay less in their geographical or cultural authenticity than in their capacity to evoke a shared identity across distance. Yet the significance of this visual language extended beyond its connection to a distant homeland: it also provided a means of connecting Shanghai’s Scottish community to a much wider network of societies across the British Empire.

The St Andrew’s Society of Shanghai was, after all, just one of many Scottish associations established throughout the Empire during the early twentieth century. The prominence accorded to its Caledonian Ball was similarly reflected elsewhere, with a 1901 article in the China Mail describing Hong Kong’s equivalent as ‘the leading event of the social calendar’.12 Indeed, accounts of these celebrations reveal striking similarities not only in the ways that colonial spaces were decorated, but also in the rituals and performances that took place within them. At Singapore’s Victoria Memorial Hall in 1910, for instance, the St Andrew’s Cross appeared alongside the Union Jack, accompanied by clan shields and displays of weaponry. Palms and bamboo framed the decorations, while ‘a few little blocks of peat’ brought ‘a whiff of Caithness bog or Hebridean marsh to the grateful Celt who brought his nose near enough’.13  A 1911 account of the Ball at Hong Kong’s City Hall similarly described the familiar combination of flags and foliage, alongside ‘correct tartan plaids’ made ‘more effective’ by displays of weaponry.14

While these were discrete local events, their shared visual vocabulary transformed different venues into iterations of the same cultural space, allowing attendees to imagine themselves as members of a community that extended beyond their immediate locality. As the China Press recognised in 1926, through such events ‘Scotsmen the world over will be united in thought and fraternal greetings will be flashed over the wires linking up those in far distant lands’.15

Indeed, contemporary newspaper accounts frequently emphasised the extent of the greetings exchanged between Scottish societies across Asia. At the 1907 Shanghai celebration, ‘telegrams of congratulation were received from the kindred Societies of Hongkong, Hankow, Foochow, Tientsin, Chefoo, Yokohama, and Kobe’, and displayed within the hall during the event.16 Similarly, a 1910 report in the Straits Times devoted considerable attention to greetings received at Singapore’s Caledonian Ball from ‘Brither Scots’ across the region. Such exchanges brought the wider network of Scottish associations into the celebrations themselves, making otherwise distant communities present within the event and reinforcing relationships that extended well beyond the city in which it was held.17

Through these shared performances of Scottish identity, those dancing in Shanghai’s Town Hall could therefore understand themselves as part of the same cultural and social world as those gathered at Singapore’s Raffles Hotel or Hong Kong’s City Hall. Indeed, these colonial venues may have offered a more immediate sense of belonging than the streets of Edinburgh itself. The Caledonian Ball was consequently more than a celebration of Scottishness overseas: through the repeated transformation of local spaces, the performance of familiar cultural practices and the cultivation of connections between societies, it helped produce and sustain the wider networks through which the British Empire was experienced.

  1.   ‘St. George’s Day Celebrations’, Social Shanghai, 11 (January-June 1911), p.134.  [↩]
  2. Ibid. [↩]
  3. ‘The Caledonian Ball’, Social Shanghai, 4 (July-December 1907), p.315. [↩]
  4. See Tanja Bueltmann, Clubbing Together: Ethnicity, Civility and Formal Sociability in the Scottish Diaspora to 1930 (Liverpool, 2015); Tanja Bueltmann, ‘Ethnic Associationalism and Networking among the Scots in Asia: A Longitudinal Comparison, c.1870 to the Present’ in T. M. Devine, Angela McCarthy  (eds.) The Scottish Experience in Asia, c.1700 to the Present (Cambridge, 2017), pp.259-282.; Isabella Jackson, ‘The Shanghai Scottish: Volunteers with Scottish, Imperial and Local Identities, 1914–41’ in T. M. Devine, Angela McCarthy  (eds.) The Scottish Experience in Asia, c.1700 to the Present (Cambridge, 2017), pp. 235-257; Kim Sullivan, ‘Scots by Association: Clubs and Societies in the Scottish Diaspora’ in Murray Stewart Leith, Duncan Sim (eds.) The Modern Scottish Diaspora: Contemporary Debates and Perspectives (Edinburgh, 2014), pp. 47-63. [↩]
  5. See Robert Bickers, Settlers and Expatriates (Oxford, 2010). [↩]
  6. ‘The Caledonian Ball’, Social Shanghai, 8 (July-December 1909), pp.281-2.; ‘The Caledonian Ball’, Social Shanghai, 10 (July-December 1910), p.248. [↩]
  7. Ibid.. [↩]
  8. Ibid .. [↩]
  9. Social Shanghai, 8 (July-December 1909), p.281. [↩]
  10. Sullivan, ‘Scots by Association: Clubs and Societies in the Scottish Diaspora’, pp.52-3. [↩]
  11. Social Shanghai, 8 (July-December 1909), p.281; Social Shanghai, 10 (July-December 1910), p.248.  [↩]
  12. ‘St. Andrew’s Day Ball’, China Mail, Hong Kong, 30th November 1901, p.4. [↩]
  13. ‘St Andrew’s Ball’, Straits Times, Singapore, 1st December 1910, p.7. [↩]
  14. ‘St. Andrew’s Ball’, China Mail, Hong Kong, 1st December 1911, p.4. [↩]
  15. ‘St. Andrew’s Day’, China Press, 30th November 1926, p.2. [↩]
  16. Social Shanghai, 4 (July-December 1907), p.315. [↩]
  17. Straits Times, Singapore, 1st December 1910, p.7. [↩]