Western Influence on the Modern Japanese Home

During the Meiji period in Japan, there were many developments in the urban sphere, especially in the home. Edward S. Morse, an American observer, recorded his thoughts about Japanese housing and modernisation in his book Japanese Homes and Their Surroundings (1886). In his book, Morse writes about the architecture, arrangement, and construction of the Japanese home, while comparing them to homes in the West. Throughout Morse’s account of the Japanese home, there are comments of both admiration and criticism. It is in Morse’s criticisms that the cultural differences present between the West and Japan become clear. Morse’s account shows how Western expectations of domestic comfort and home design shaped perceptions of Japanese homes, which suggests that the modernisation of Japanese homes was not simply a wave of new innovation efforts, but was a more conscious effort of modernisation partly influenced by Western ideas.

Morse’s account features many opinions regarding the structure and contents of the Japanese home, some of which he regarded as quite admirable. Morse specifically enjoyed the craftsmanship of the Japanese home, writing, “their methods were not only the simplest and most economical, but they answered all the requirements. One is amazed to see how many firemen can gather upon such a roof without its yielding.”1 Morse had a few positive comments about the Japanese home, mostly about the structural ingenuity and architectural design of the home. However, despite any positives that Morse found, Morse had several fundamental issues with how the Japanese home was constructed, finding the Japanese home particularly deficient in privacy as well as comfort. Morse thought it uncomfortable that the divisions used in Japanese homes were primarily sliding doors or non-permanent dividers: “In the Japanese house, on the contrary, there are two or more sides that have no permanent walls.”2 Morse finds the lack of permanent walls to be a design flaw, one that contrasts with the homes in the West, which often featured multiple permanent walls and doors to shut spaces to ensure privacy. The core theme present in Morse’s account is how frequently he uses Western standards as a measure for the successful construction of a home. Morse often uses Western expectations and norms of domestic comfort, e.g., enclosed spaces and less open-concept construction. These criticisms of what Japanese homes lack in comparison to Western homes eventually become the very aspects that are incorporated into the Japanese home.

Morse’s account reflects an early stage of Japanese home modernisation, when Western ideas began to influence the Japanese home. Morse’s account can also be better understood when positioned within the broader context of Japanese housing reform and modernisation. In Jordan Sand’s House and Home in Modern Japan, he describes how several significant changes occurred in domestic environments between 1880 and 1930 (this includes Morse’s writings in the Meiji period). Sand writes, “In the final stage of the conversion, rooms gain distinct functions (significantly including a separate bedroom for the couple), floor-living is abandoned, and the ‘empty ceremony’ of traditional guest reception gives way to family leisure.”3 Sand is describing the work of a prominent Japanese modernist architect, Tanabe Junkichi. His vision of comfortable “Western-style living,” complete with functionally divided rooms, is the exact ideal that Morse found lacking in the Japanese home from before, showing the integration of Western domestic ideals eventually becoming physically present in the Japanese home.

There are several elements that the Western onlooker Edward S. Morse disliked about Japanese homes, one of which was the seating arrangement, specifically that of floor sitting. Morse states, “The sitting posture on the floor is painful…I find that our chairs are painful to the Japanese until they become accustomed to them. “4 This again proves Western influence, as down the line, domestic spaces in Japan began transitioning from floor sitting to chair sitting. In Housing in Postwar Japan, Ann Waswo writes, “the western-style, chair-sitting way of life that had been confined to the DK began to spread”5 into other areas of the home over time. Demonstrating that Western ideals eventually became incorporated into Japanese homes. Ann Waswo also explains the transition from traditional Japanese-style furnishings to the adoption of Westernised furnishings. Waswo writes, “the workshops and factories that sprang up to supply that market soon branched out into producing other items of western-style furniture.”6 The furniture production here demonstrates demand for Western-style furniture pieces, now showing that some Western ideals were not only integrated into the Japanese home, but some were even popularised.

Morse’s Japanese Homes and Their Surroundings speaks to how Western ideals began to influence certain elements in the Japanese home during the Meiji period in Japan. Morse’s account is useful as an early perspective during the start of Westernisation efforts in the Japanese home. Additionally, Morse’s admiration, as well as his criticism, reflects how Western cultural expectations eventually became physically manifested in Japanese domestic spaces. Sand’s House and Home in Modern Japan builds on Morse’s account by demonstrating how Western ideals manifested in tangible, physical changes in Japanese homes. Ann Waswo’s Housing in Postwar Japan demonstrates how this trend of Westernisation in the home extended into later time periods in Japan. All of these developments show that the modernisation of Japanese homes was not just about architectural improvements or innovations, but rather a transformation of domestic spaces that was partly influenced by Western ideals for the home.

  1. Edward S. Morse,  Japanese Homes and Their Surroundings (Boston: Ticknor and Company, 1886), 19–20. [↩]
  2. Morse,  Japanese Homes and Their Surroundings, 7. [↩]
  3.  Jordan Sand, House and Home in Modern Japan: Architecture, Domestic Space, and Bourgeois Culture, 1880–1930 (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Asia Center, 2003), 178. [↩]
  4. Morse, Japanese Homes and Their Surroundings, 12. [↩]
  5. Ann Waswo,  Housing in Postwar Japan: A Social History (Abingdon: Routledge, 2013), 93. [↩]
  6. Waswo, Housing in Postwar Japan, 73. [↩]