My ongoing research examines how the collapse of a particular spatial and political order was experienced by the inhabitants of Shanghai’s International Settlement when Japanese occupation brought an end to decades of Western extraterritorial privilege and municipal autonomy. Shanghai’s experience of the Sino-Japanese War was distinctive in the gradual manner in which the city underwent conquest and occupation. Following Japan’s victory in the Battle of Shanghai in 1937, the Japanese occupied the Chinese-administered parts of the city, while the International Settlement and French Concession remained outside direct Japanese control. From 1937 to December 1941, these foreign-administered enclaves constituted what became known as the ‘Lonely Island’ (孤岛), where the insecurity of Japanese military encirclement coexisted with a degree of protection afforded by Western extraterritoriality. In this post, I will first introduce the rationale and methodology that underpinned the research, and then lay down some observations I have made over preliminary research.
This research focuses on how the inhabitants of the International Settlement experienced the collapse of this order following the Japanese occupation of December 1941. It focuses especially on the Western (especially Anglo-American) population who are simultaneously ‘enemy nationals’ and the long-established foreign interests in the International Settlement. For them, the takeover represented more than the loss of a major commercial centre — it disrupted an established system of municipal government, foreign privilege, and social hierarchy, with Japanese occupation exposing the fragility of a social order built upon the assumption of Western supremacy. The foreign presence, previously sustained by extraterritorial rights and the authority of the Shanghai Municipal Council (SMC), could no longer guarantee the security or privileged position of its inhabitants. The occupation was therefore a moment of both physical disruption and psychological disillusionment. Crucially, this transformation was experienced in spatial as well as political terms. The International Settlement had long embodied Western extraterritorial authority through its control over municipal institutions, public infrastructure and the regulation of urban space. Japanese occupation consequently unsettled established assumptions about who could govern, occupy and exercise authority over the city. Although existing works have examined in considerable detail how the populations of the foreign concessions experienced the years 1941–45, most remain largely narrative accounts and lack a strong analytical dimension.1 Most importantly, the occupation’s psychological and spatial ramifications in Shanghai have yet to be fully elucidated.
Hence, this research pays particular attention to how established practices and expectations surrounding public spaces, social life and municipal services were disrupted — or maintained — under the new administration. How such changes and continuities affected the mentality of Shanghai’s Western population is central to the enquiry. Beyond the existing contextual literature on wartime Shanghai, this research draws upon a diverse body of primary sources. Official records, particularly the Shanghai Municipal Police archives and Shanghai Municipal Council reports, will provide evidence of how the existing municipal authorities negotiated their position under Japanese occupation. Along with newspapers, accessible through various digital archives, these sources will also supplement the official accounts with contemporary reports and anecdotal evidence of changes in urban life.2 On a more individual level, memoirs and personal accounts written by Jewish, Western and Chinese residents of wartime Shanghai form a substantial part of the analysis, offering perspectives on how the occupation was experienced in everyday life — from lighting regulations and counter-terrorism drills to the imposition of neighbourhood surveillance and, eventually, internment.3 Regarding the spatial focus of the work, these personal testimonies also offer insights into how space was intimately perceived and experienced by residents on the ground. Taken together, these sources allow the research to connect the transformation of Shanghai’s political and municipal order with more immediate, personal experiences, thereby illustrating the profound changes to the city’s spatiality brought about by the fall of extraterritorial Shanghai. Finally, all this serves to show the various ways in which the expatriate population of Shanghai conceptualised their existence in the cosmopolitan city — as both its most prominent administrators and constructors, and a somewhat detached pseudo-colonial overclass — just as that existence was coming to an end.
Preliminary readings of numerous secondary sources and several memoirs have revealed a number of noteworthy themes. First, like the preceding gudao era, the occupation period cannot be described in absolute terms. Various scholars have questioned the term gudao in light of its inaccurate implication of the foreign settlements’ total seclusion and security, pointing to various instances in which Japanese authorities had already begun to encroach upon Anglo-American power in the concessions.4 Similarly, the period of occupation after 1941 was not immediately a doomsday scenario. Until the introduction of internment for all Allied nationals in January 1943, most Anglo-Americans — while subject to constant surveillance and occasional interrogation — were more or less able to get on with their lives. Although many businesses and institutions were placed under Japanese administration or surveillance, they did not, by any means, undergo complete deprivation. In fact, as one Chinese memoir recounts, these foreigners adopted a ‘live in the moment’ mentality: ‘When their cars were “requisitioned” by the Japanese, they turned to bicycles — pedalling out each morning to buy groceries.’5 It was not until October 1942 that they were banned from entering entertainment venues such as clubs, cinemas and racecourses.6 The takeover is therefore mediated through a balance of change and continuity. Beneath the shadow of the rising sun, the maintenance of a pseudo-normal life and the agency individuals demonstrated in the face of great adversity should not be neglected in favour of a dramatic, dichotomous narrative. The persistence of this outlook is illustrated by the fact that, even after the liberation of Shanghai, with extraterritoriality already abolished in 1943, many Anglo-Americans still dreamed of their restoration to the privileged position they had once enjoyed in a Settlement that no longer existed.7
The Japanese occupation also brought a cornucopia of spatial implications. On 8 December 1941 alone, all the buildings along the Bund — previously a showcase for Anglo-American hegemony — had to raise the Japanese flag rather than the Union Jack or the Stars and Stripes, as Japanese troops thronged the streets of the Settlement and its residents could do nothing but watch.8 In the months and years that followed, large billboards were erected to celebrate Japan’s triumphs in Southeast Asia; the streets were used to parade Allied POWs to intimidate the Anglo-Americans; and the Great War Cenotaph and statues dedicated to Anglo-American luminaries on the Bund were torn down.9 The Japanese authorities thus made a spatial declaration of the end of Anglo-American hegemony in the city, ironically presenting it as part of a move towards the decolonisation of China. This new spatial order was not merely materially constructed, but also experienced by the people who inhabited it. A telling episode occurred when the internees designated for the Pudong camp were assembled from the Puxi area and collectively transported from the Bund. We can only imagine what the Anglo-Americans might have felt as they saw the Huangpu stripped of their formidable battleships and the Bund now decorated with the flags of the rising sun, while sailing into the uncertainties of the Pudong internment camp, likely in a state of disillusionment and deep uncertainty.10 Other changes to daily life in Shanghai — especially its growing militarisation and increasing restrictions — can also be examined from a spatial perspective. The imposition of the Bao Jia system (for neighbourhood surveillance and administration), alongside lighting and electricity restrictions, altered the previous spatiality of downtown Shanghai.11 Far from being a place of unimpeded movement and constant flows of traffic and people, the city became increasingly segmented, with people constantly stopped at intersections for searches and inspections. The iconic neon lights that had illuminated Shanghai’s nightscape were eventually banned. This signalled the end of the carefree pre-1941 nightlife. It’s curious how contemporary Shanghainese use ‘the break of day / 天亮’ to refer to an anticipated liberation — the phrase might well carry a literal (the absence of lights under Japanese occupation) as well as figurative meaning.12 Turning to the Western populations, both visually and behaviourally, the indulgent and luxurious social life enjoyed by them was suppressed by the new administration. These are all very preliminary observations, and as my research progresses, some new points will emerge, while others may be discarded or modified. Nevertheless, I am confident that I have plenty to work with. Exploring the experience of an expatriate population in a time of radical change is itself a tantalising topic, and being able to illuminate this largely forgotten chapter of history in the place where I grew up provides an additional attraction. Tortuous as the reading has been, my enthusiasm for these fascinating stories has only grown stronger.
- Bernard Wasserstein, Secret War in Shanghai: Treachery, Subversion and Collaboration in the Second World War (London, 2017); Greg Leck, Captives of Empire: The Japanese Internment of Allied Civilians in China 1941-1945 (Bangor, 2006 [↩]
- Preliminary newspapers I am planning to consult are: the North China Herald and the China Weekly Review (as the most prominent publishing organs), the Shanghai Times (a collaborationist paper), and the Shenbao (as a Chinese source) [↩]
- Ruth Barr and Betty Barr, Ruth’s Record: The Diary of an American in Japanese-Occupied Shanghai, 1941–1945 (Hong Kong, 2017); Juyin Tao, Gu Dao Jian Wen: Kang Zhan Shi Qi De Shang Hai (Shanghai, 1979); James Ballard, Miracles of Life: Shanghai to Shepperton, An Autobiography (London, 2008), epub. [↩]
- ‘Introduction’ in Christian Henriot and Wen-Hsin Yeh (eds) In the Shadow of the Rising Sun: Shanghai under Japanese Occupation (Cambridge 2004), p. 6 [↩]
- Tao, Gu Dao Jian Wen, p. 163 [↩]
- Ibid. [↩]
- Greg Leck, Captives of Empire, pp. 406-410. [↩]
- Tao, Gu Dao Jian Wen, p. 109. [↩]
- Ibid., pp. 153-154; Wasserstein, Secret War in Shanghai, pp. 105-106. [↩]
- Leck, Captives of Empire, pp. 126-127 [↩]
- Tao, Gu Dao Jian Wen, pp. 124-127.; Leck, Captives of Empire, pp. 74-77. [↩]
- Tao, Gu Dao Jian Wen, p. 124. [↩]